Mission: Capture M&G - Guptas advised on buying out one of their most vocal critics

06 June 2017 - 08:14
Oakbay Investments CEO Nazeem Howa and former Oakbay nonexecutive chairman Atul Gupta.
Image: GALLO IMAGES Oakbay Investments CEO Nazeem Howa and former Oakbay nonexecutive chairman Atul Gupta.

The Guptas considered buying one of their most vociferous critics, the Mail & Guardian newspaper, in a James Bond-style "Project M", leaked e-mails show.

The e-mails, from January 28 2016, show that Zimbabwe's Alpha Media - which publishes three national newspapers: News Day, The Standard and the Zimbabwe Independent - was also in the family's sights.

In an e-mail with the subject line "Some early thoughts on Project M" sent by the former chief executive of Gupta company Oakbay, Nazeem Howa, to Rajesh "Tony" Gupta, Howa speaks about the possibility of buying the M&G and its sister titles, "which are indeed brands which have great recognition factor in South Africa across all sectors of society".

  • #GuptaEmails: Gupta fixer paid for minister's Dubai stayCommunications Minister Ayanda Dlodlo's stay at a luxury hotel in Dubai in 2015 was secured by Sahara Computers‚ a company owned by the Gupta family.

"The newspaper is champion a position [sic] that President Zuma is corrupt and should be relieved of his responsibility. They have made it their focus to find ways to support the #Zumamustfall campaign, and the family and our group have become convenience [sic] pawns in their strategy to unseat the President," Howa writes.

He then lists statistics on the circulation and advertising revenue of the newspaper which, according to him, had been hurt by its editorial position.


"Editorial position has certainly been a factor in this decline and one would question how quickly one can reclaim the lost government advertising spend, and how much of an editorial positioning change will be needed to achieve that," Howa writes.

He ends the e-mail by saying the estimated cost of the acquisition would be R20-million "which I would argue is not a good deal at all".

At the time of the e-mail, articles were appearing frequently in the Mail & Guardian revealing the inner workings of the Gupta family. The newspaper was among the family's fiercest media critics.

  • Ministers implicated in fresh #GuptaEmails scandalsDeputy finance minister Sfiso Buthelezi and mineral resources minister Mosebenzi Zwane were on Monday implicated in fresh allegations of being “captured” by the Gupta family.

A report in the newspaper in 2013, which referenced a Sunday Times exposé that alleged Tony Gupta had tried to bribe a senior official at SA Airways, led to both newspapers being sued by the family for R500-million for defamation - possibly the biggest defamation suit in South African legal history - but the suit never went to trial.

Trevor Ncube, deputy executive chairman of M&G Media and publisher of the M&G, is also the chairman of Zimbabwe's Apha Media.

Asked to comment on Monday, Ncube said the M&G had not changed ownership since 2002.

  • Denel runs to Guptas: Arms group head ‘gave them top-secret info’The chairman of state-owned arms manufacturer and procurer Denel, Daniel Lugisani Mantsha, appears to have fed sensitive classified company information to the Gupta family, leaked e-mails show.

"As normal with any business we get approached by entrepreneurs expressing an interest in acquiring our business," Ncube said when asked if he had ever received offers from Gupta-linked businesses.

Asked if he would have declined a purchase offer from the Gupta family, Ncube said: "The Mail & Guardian is a national institution of which we are mere custodians. We have a duty to protect its brand of journalism, particularly cutting- edge investigative journalism.

"It would be reckless and irresponsible to off-load the business to anybody likely to undermine the 30-year-plus legacy of fiercely independent journalism," Ncube said.

The Guptas' attorney, Gert van der Merwe, said he had advised his clients not to respond to media inquiries until the veracity of the e-mails had been established.