Moyane tried to suspend Sars employees without due process‚ tax inquiry hears

28 September 2018 - 14:28 By Amil Umraw
Embattled Sars commissioner Tom Moyane is said to have given Hlengani Mathebula a 'hit list' that ought to have been fired without following due process
Embattled Sars commissioner Tom Moyane is said to have given Hlengani Mathebula a 'hit list' that ought to have been fired without following due process
Image: Esa Alexander

Suspended South African Revenue Service (Sars) commissioner Tom Moyane allegedly provided a hit list of senior officials he wanted suspended without due process to his then enforcement manager‚ along with another list of replacements he wanted appointed in their place.

These startling revelations were made by chief officer for governance at Sars‚ Hlengani Mathebula‚ who served as enforcement boss in 2016 when the request was said to be made. He made submissions before retired judge Robert Nugent’s commission of inquiry into Sars on Friday.

Mathebula said he refused the request.

“My working relationship with the commissioner [Moyane] started off the same way as most: cordial‚ full of enthusiasm‚ optimism and good will. In May 2016‚ various developments ensued which soured the relationship between myself and the commissioner‚” Mathebula said.

“I expressed a different opinion‚ which was seen as opposition and sometimes betrayal. Resultantly‚ various investigations were instituted against me.”

Mathebula said that during his time as head of enforcement‚ Moyane allegedly called him to his office and gave him a list of names for people he was to “dismiss or suspend”. He said Moyane also gave him an additional list of names for people to be appointed in senior and executive positions – also without following due process.

“I wasn’t comfortable to investigate people without information and simply being given the names. [Moyane] came to me with names of people he wanted me to appoint in positions. I had discomfort around the process that I could just appoint them. The commissioner was unhappy about that‚” Mathebula said.

On the hit list were veteran investigators like Kumaran Moodley and Yousuf Denath‚ who were probing high-profile individuals in the tobacco industry. Moyane allegedly wanted controversial figures like Yegan Mundie and Gobi Makhanya to be appointed in key positions.

Nugent and his team grilled Mathebula on a memorandum he had signed in the same year to investigate and institute disciplinary processes against Moodley and Denath based on information from Mundie alleging that they were colluding with British American Tobacco to intimidate and harass competing tobacco dealers.

But this memorandum came after the State Security Agency handed information to Sars pertaining to an intercept of Mundie talking to a tobacco smuggler‚ where Mundie allegedly provided information on the smuggler’s rivals. Denath brought this to the attention of Mathebula and Moyane‚ but it was never acted upon. Instead‚ Denath was suspended.

Mundie handed the memorandum over to Mathebula for his signature and recommended that a case be registered with the police‚ disciplinary action be taken against Sars employees and a new team of auditors be appointed to assess British American Tobacco.

It was Mathebula’s signature that triggered a “sham” investigation into Denath.

Mathebula was also made to account for signing off on a new intelligence unit‚ a task team to investigate illicit tobacco trading and the involvement of Sars officials in various syndicates‚ which has been dubbed the “new rogue unit”.

The commission previously heard how the unit‚ which reported directly to Moyane and was headed by Mundie‚ was used to target senior Sars officials.

Mathebula said although he signed off for the establishment of the team‚ it reported directly to Moyane.

He also approved that the team use a safe house and monitoring equipment‚ similar to that afforded to the high-risk investigation unit‚ later dubbed the “rogue unit”‚ which was deemed unlawful by Sars only a year earlier.

“There was no equipment that I authorised to be purchased. There was never a safe house that was ever utilised. In the initial memo there were a lot of things I had read about in the media similar to the rogue unit. I asked it be changed drastically. The safe house was an oversight‚” Mathebula said.

He further alleged that Moyane pressured him into signing the memorandum for the team. Mundie‚ who was appointed fraud and investigations manager‚ resigned under a cloud earlier this year after being suspended on allegations of misconduct.

The inquiry continues.

X