We've got news for you.

Register on TimesLIVE at no cost to receive newsletters, read exclusive articles & more.
Register now

Press Council expels SA Jewish Report as member

This is the first time a member has been expelled

27 May 2022 - 17:15
The Press Council of SA said the SA Jewish Report refused to obey rulings against it. File photo.
The Press Council of SA said the SA Jewish Report refused to obey rulings against it. File photo.
Image: 123RF/LUKAS GOJDA/ File photo

The SA Jewish Report has been expelled from the Press Council of SA (PCSA) with immediate effect. 

This is the first time in 20 years the council has expelled a member.

The SA Jewish Report was established in 1998 and caters to the Jewish community in SA. 

In a statement on Friday afternoon, PCSA executive director Latiefa Mobara said the publication refused to obey rulings by the acting press ombud and PCSA chair of appeals judge Bernard Ngoepe. 

Press Council chair judge Phillip Levinsohn said the decision was taken after lengthy correspondence and after the SA Jewish Report had refused to obey the rulings against it.

“The SA Jewish Report appealed the ruling by acting ombud Johan Retief in the complaint, SA BDS Coalition and GIWUSA v SA Jewish Report, but their application for leave to appeal was dismissed by judge Ngoepe,” Levinsohn said.

The complaint was lodged by Hassen Lorgat of the Palestine Solidarity Alliance on behalf of the SA Boycott Division and Sanction (BDS) Coalition and the General Industrial Workers Union of SA (Giwusa), after a cartoon on the Clover dairy labour dispute was published on their respective social media pages.

At the time the Israeli Central Bottling Company was given the go-ahead to take over Clover.

On October 22 2020, Jewish Report published an article titled Antisemitic Clover cartoon is BDS’s sour ‘last gasp'.

BDS Coalition is a movement for organisations in SA advocating for the withdrawal of Israel from the occupied Palestinian territories.

The complaint was that the publication labelled them as anti-Semites.

Levinsohn stated that the council spent time and effort corresponding with the SA Jewish Report in an attempt to resolve the issue.

“They then refused to publish the ruling against them. SA Jewish Report also abandoned a second complaint, SA BDS Coalition vs SA Jewish Report, after losing another application for leave to appeal by judge Ngoepe.”

This application was brought by SA BDS after an article published in Jewish Report on April 15 2021, with the headline: BDS attack on Unterhalter ‘defamatory and shameful’.

Levinsohn said: “The SA Jewish Report then attempted to withdraw from the Press Council rather than publish the rulings. You cannot do that.

“It is a great pity that we have had to expel them, but we cannot tolerate a member of the Press Council wilfully refusing to obey rulings of the press ombud and the chair of appeals.

“The Press Council is a voluntary, co-regulatory, public-dominated body which, inter alia [among other things], mediates and adjudicates complaints against its members in terms of the press code.”

He said the press code is there to ensure ethical, fair, journalism.

“Those who join the PCSA commit to being bound by, and to publish, rulings of the press ombud and the press council’s appeals bodies. Parties who are dissatisfied with press ombuds’ rulings have the right to take them on appeal to our appeals panel, headed by an eminent, retired judge, and if still unhappy can take the process on judicial review.

“What our member publications cannot do is simply refuse to publish rulings against them. Compliance by members is essential. To refuse undermines the Press Council and is unfair to the complainants.” 

The SA Jewish report told TimesLIVE it had withdrawn from the press council six months ago.

“We withdrew our membership from the SA press council six months ago after it became evident to us that the press council lacked the skills to perform their job competently, fairly and without prejudice,” said chairperson of the SA Jewish Report Howard Sackstein.

The publication said: “A dispute arose when the SA Jewish Report reported the opinion of two internationally renowned experts on racist anti-Semitism, who called a particular cartoon antisemitic.

“The cartoon depicted a fat greedy Jew shoving money into his mouth, almost identical to traditional racist antisemitic tropes used by the Nazis. The acting press ombud overruled the opinions of these international experts without even convening a hearing on the matter. Furthermore, the press council denied the SA Jewish Report the right of appeal or to have the matter fully adjudicated before a competent authority.

“Through its failure to recognise the racist undertones of the cartoon, the press council became party to the perpetuation of racism, hatred and bigotry in SA. By calling on the SA Jewish Report to apologise to racists, the press council discredited itself and failed the people of SA.”

The publication said it had informed the council that it was “embarrassed” to be associated with it. 


Support independent journalism by subscribing to the Sunday Times. Just R20 for the first month.


Would you like to comment on this article or view other readers' comments? Register (it’s quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.