Vatican synod faces stronger calls for women's participation

23 October 2018 - 17:33 By Reuters
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
Kenyan nun Lucy Nderi smiles before the start of a synod session led by pope Francis at the Vatican last week.
Kenyan nun Lucy Nderi smiles before the start of a synod session led by pope Francis at the Vatican last week.
Image: Max Rossi/Reuters

Catholic women say there's a clerical stained glass ceiling in the Vatican, and they want to shatter it.

They want to vote in major policy meetings. They want pope Francis to deliver on his promise to put more women in senior positions in the Holy See's administration. And some of them say they want to be priests.

"Knock knock! Who's there? More than half the church!" several dozen Catholic women chanted outside the Vatican on October 3, the first day of this year's synod of bishops from around the world.

The impression that the church, when it comes to power, is ultimately a male church must be overcome in the universal church and also here in the Vatican. It is high time
Archbishop Reinhard Marx of Munich

The role of women in the Catholic church has been a recurring theme at the month-long meeting, which brings together some 300 bishops, priests, nuns and lay participants. Only about 35 are women.

The subject has come up in speeches on the floor, in small group discussions and at news conferences by participants in the gathering, officially titled "Young People, Faith and Discernment of Vocation".

Only "synod fathers", including bishops and specially appointed or elected male representatives, are allowed to vote on the final recommendations to be sent to the pope, who will take them into consideration when he writes his own document. Other participants are non-voting observers, auditors or experts.

Some of the attendees have pointed to what they say is a contradiction in the rules of the synod, which takes place every few years on a different theme.

This year, two "brothers", lay men who are not ordained, are being allowed to vote in their capacity as superiors general of their religious orders.

But sister Sally Marie Hodgdon, an American nun who also is not ordained, cannot vote even though she is the superior general of the Sisters of St. Joseph of Chambery.

"I am a superior general. I am a sister. So in theory, logically you would think I would have the right to vote," said Hodgdon, who is also vice-president of the International Union of Superiors General (UISG), an umbrella group of Catholic nuns.

The membership of female religious orders is about three times larger than that of male orders.

A petition demanding that women have the right to vote at synods has collected 9,000 signatures since it opened online at the start of this meeting. It is sponsored by 10 Catholic lay groups seeking change in the church, including greater rights for women and gays and a bigger role for the laity.

The cause has won some influential clerical male backers.

Last week superiors general of three major male religious orders - the Jesuits, the Dominicans and one branch of the Franciscans - expressed support for changes in synod rules in order to allow women to vote in the future.

Backing also came from cardinal Reinhard Marx, archbishop of Munich, president of the German bishops conference and one of the most influential Catholic leaders in Europe.

"We must face up to the often uncomfortable and impatient questions of young people about equal rights for women also in the church," Marx said in his speech to the synod. "The impression that the church, when it comes to power, is ultimately a male church must be overcome in the universal church and also here in the Vatican. It is high time."

Francis has promised to put more women in senior roles in the Vatican. But more than five years after he was elected, there are only six women in such roles. Five are lay women and one is a nun. None of them heads a department.

In June Francis said he had to "fight" internal resistance to appoint a female deputy head of the Vatican's press office. He said he had to use "persuasion," an apparent reference to the powerful conservative wing of what has been an institution run exclusively by males for 2,000 years.

subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now