'We'd rather have raises': New York Times' lunch box perk backfires amid work-from-home protest

14 September 2022 - 08:00 By Jo Constantz and Josh Eidelson
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
The company is one of many turning up the heat on in-person work mandates that have so far been unsuccessful.
The company is one of many turning up the heat on in-person work mandates that have so far been unsuccessful.
Image: Bloomberg

Hundreds of New York Times  employees are working from home this week in defiance of the company’s renewed return-to-office push. 

More than 1,200 people, who are the majority of the journalists and tech workers represented by the NewsGuild of New York, pledged not to return to the office Monday in an effort to get the Times to negotiate over RTO plans, according to the union.

“Health and safety policies are a part of contract negotiations and they have to be bargained over,” Times software engineer Carrie Price said in an interview Monday. “Being in charge of our own personal risk assessment is important to our membership... Being asked to give up that ability to be in control of my own personal safety for myself and my loved ones, is something that we don’t want and it hasn’t been negotiated over.”

The journalists have been without a contract since March 2021 and staff haven’t had pay increases in more than two years despite decades-high inflation and rent increases. Meanwhile, they say the company has done exceptionally well in recent years and executives are making millions of dollars each year.

Staffers say this week’s protest comes after months of stalled contract negotiations. In June, when Joseph Kahn became the paper’s executive editor, union organisers wrote a letter with almost 900 signatures to appeal for a new contract. Two weeks ago, after seeing no progress, more than 300 employees, many of whom are paid significantly less than some of the Times’ star reporters, wrote personal emails to senior leadership describing how they’ve been struggling to keep up with surging costs of living.

On Monday, the Times offered branded lunch boxes to welcome employees back to the office.

“I imagine that whoever decided to do a lunch box meant it really well, but I think for us these little incentives are just not enough,” said Andrea Zagata, a senior staff editor, in an interview. “We’d rather have raises, frankly, or a contract.”

“We presented the NewsGuild with a wage proposal that would offer contractual increases of 10% over the remaining two-and-a half years of the new contract,” said Danielle Rhoades Ha, a company spokesperson. “That is significantly higher than in recent Times Guild contracts.”

The NewsGuild disputes this, saying the company’s math doesn’t add up.

This isn’t the first time the company has attempted to get its workers back to their desks. The last return to office deadline was set for June, though employees protested the move on Twitter and it was later pushed back following updated health guidance from New York City.

Public clashes with union workers are also not a new thing for the Times. In August 2021, hundreds of tech workers staged a walkout to protest unfair labour practices and alleged union-busting, later winning the election to form one of the largest tech worker unions in the US. Wirecutter journalists held a Black Friday strike last November and then reached a contract deal the following month.

The high-profile tension at the Times echoes that playing out at other offices across the country. Apple, among other companies, chose Labor Day as its new line in the sand for workers to return to their desks. The tech giant had pushed back its RTO date multiple times in the face of the rising ire from employees unhappy with the policy. Meanwhile, Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley are easing some Covid-19 policies to draw more workers back to the office.

More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com


subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now

Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.