Some MDBs provide guarantees or structures that help reduce the risks, for example by hedging the risk of a collapse in the local currency. At COP29, some banks have flagged new initiatives, including a move by the US to guarantee $1bn of existing loans to governments by the Asian Development Bank so it can lend a further $4.5bn to climate-friendly projects.
The EBRD's Renaud-Basso told Reuters it was also looking to guarantee sovereign lending to free up more money, without providing further details.
Guarantees aside, the reluctance of some development banks to play the junior partner in project lending, amid pressure to land big deals and maximise their own returns, was leaving them in competition with private sector investors, according to half a dozen sources in the industry.
Gianpiero Nacci, EBRD director for sustainable business and infrastructure, said while MDBs were starting to change their culture and structures to make them more focused on attracting private sector investment, it was a “work in progress”.
“We're increasingly incentivising our banking teams to focus on mobilisation,” he said, noting the EBRD is introducing internal targets beyond its own direct investment.
Given the scale of the climate challenge, some development experts are choosing to go it alone, among them Hubert Danso, CEO of Africa Investor, a platform that connects private investors with green infrastructure projects on the continent.
“We have an MDB market failure which is incapable of crowding in the private capital required,” he said.
CULTURAL HURDLES
In an August document, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which tracks the climate finance efforts of multilateral institutions, found lack of data was a “major obstacle” to raising private investment to the required levels.
The previously unpublished report, reviewed by Reuters, said a shortfall in transparent data was leading to private investors mispricing investment risk.
“For efficiency of markets, data is critical,” said Haje Schutte, a deputy director at the OECD. “There is an ethical and fairness dimension to that. The public sector institutions have a role to beyond their institutional self-interests.”
Beyond B-loans? Development banks seek private money for climate change fight
Image: REUTERS/Maxim Shemetov
As officials from around the world strive this week to reach a deal on funding for poorer countries to tackle climate change, investment manager Rob Drijkoningen is the sort of person they're hoping will help get them there.
Drijkoningen is head of emerging market debt at US asset manager Neuberger Berman, which holds $27bn (R489bn) in sovereign and corporate debt from developing countries. He should be a natural partner for multilateral development banks (MDBs) looking to find private sector investors for projects to slow climate change or cope with its effects.
Boosting private sector investment is, for rich nations, a crucial part of clinching a deal at the COP29 climate talks in Azerbaijan this week on a global commitment for annual funding to fight climate change, dubbed the New Collective Quantified Goal. Development banks committed to increase their lending to poorer countries to $120bn (R21-trillion) a year by 2030. They also pledged to bring in an additional $65bn (R1.1-trillion) annually in private sector cash to those nations.
However, Drijkoningen, after speaking to the European Investment Bank (EIB) and European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) about potential deals this year, decided there were too many hurdles to investment.
Development banks, he said, are not willing to open their books and share enough information about investments risks. Nor do they allow private investors to pick and choose the projects that interest them. For asset managers facing limited appetite from clients for long-term infrastructure assets in developing nations, the obstacles make investment unappealing.
IN PICS | Seaweed farming brings hope to Kenyan villagers hit by climate change
“We would need to get a true sense of a level playing field, of getting equal access to information so we can appropriately assess the merits,” Drijkoningen said. “That's a cultural issue I doubt we have come close to changing.”
Cash-strapped Western governments are pinning their hopes on a huge increase in private sector investment to reach the $2-trillion-plus (R36-trillion) needed annually to help poorer countries move to greener energy and protect against the impacts of extreme weather.
After a resounding win by climate denier Donald Trump in this month's US presidential election, worries are rising that the financing gap will steadily widen if Washington — and its dollars — pulls out of the global climate fight. An ongoing, two-year reform of multilateral institutions such as the World Bank — aimed at overhauling the way they lend to make more use of their money — helped drive a 41% increase in the mobilisation of private sector funds to low income countries in 2022 across 27 development banks, a report this year showed.
The head of the EBRD, Odile Renaud-Basso, told Reuters the bank was working hard to provide more information to the private sector, but there were limits to what could be made public.
However, a Reuters analysis of lending data and interviews with two dozen development banks, climate negotiators, private sector investors and non-profits showed change at multilateral lenders needs to accelerate significantly if the private sector is to fulfil its hoped-for role.
The analysis of total aggregate lending last year provided by 14 of the world's top development banks showed for each dollar (R18.11) invested across all markets, only 88c (R15.96) of private money was sucked in.
COP29: Eskom tells climate conference of plan for going green
That fell to only 44c (R7.98) of private money to poorer countries. Here, the banks made climate finance commitments of $75bn (R1.36-trillion) and mobilised $33bn (R598.37bn) of private investment. A report by a group of independent experts for the G20 group of industrialised nations last year on how to strengthen multilateral development banks said the target that needed to be hit was $1.5 to $2 for every $1 of lending.
SLOW PROGRESS
Governments — which bankroll development banks — are pushing them to reform faster. That should result in a more ambitious funding target in Baku, and help countries to skirt a politically contentious discussion on increasing the banks' capital.
The EBRD delivers $3.58 of private money for every $1 it invests across its portfolio, up from $2 three years ago. IDB Invest, the private sector arm of the Inter-American Development Bank, has also embarked on an overhaul of its business, helping to increase IDB Group's mobilised private capital fivefold from 2019 to 2023 to $4.4bn (R79.78bn).
There are different ways for multilateral lenders to pull in private sector cash. The most established one is parcelling up parts of their own loans and selling them to private investors, freeing up money to lend again. These B-loans have been around for more than six decades.
However, Nazmeera Moola, chief sustainability officer at asset management firm Ninety One, said a raft of issues — including long lead times and returns that were sometimes unattractive — had diminished the appeal of the assets.
Meanwhile, many large institutional investors, such as pension funds and insurance companies, think of direct investing through corporate or project finance lending in emerging markets as “scary stuff”, she said.
Harmen van Wijnen, chair of the board of Dutch pension fund ABP, which has invested €1bn (R19.1bn) in B-loan funds managed by blended finance specialist ILX, said taking the leap into unfamiliar risks such as project finance in emerging markets, would need to be mitigated by guarantees from multilateral lenders.
EXPLAINER | COP29: What is the latest science on climate change?
Some MDBs provide guarantees or structures that help reduce the risks, for example by hedging the risk of a collapse in the local currency. At COP29, some banks have flagged new initiatives, including a move by the US to guarantee $1bn of existing loans to governments by the Asian Development Bank so it can lend a further $4.5bn to climate-friendly projects.
The EBRD's Renaud-Basso told Reuters it was also looking to guarantee sovereign lending to free up more money, without providing further details.
Guarantees aside, the reluctance of some development banks to play the junior partner in project lending, amid pressure to land big deals and maximise their own returns, was leaving them in competition with private sector investors, according to half a dozen sources in the industry.
Gianpiero Nacci, EBRD director for sustainable business and infrastructure, said while MDBs were starting to change their culture and structures to make them more focused on attracting private sector investment, it was a “work in progress”.
“We're increasingly incentivising our banking teams to focus on mobilisation,” he said, noting the EBRD is introducing internal targets beyond its own direct investment.
Given the scale of the climate challenge, some development experts are choosing to go it alone, among them Hubert Danso, CEO of Africa Investor, a platform that connects private investors with green infrastructure projects on the continent.
“We have an MDB market failure which is incapable of crowding in the private capital required,” he said.
CULTURAL HURDLES
In an August document, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which tracks the climate finance efforts of multilateral institutions, found lack of data was a “major obstacle” to raising private investment to the required levels.
The previously unpublished report, reviewed by Reuters, said a shortfall in transparent data was leading to private investors mispricing investment risk.
“For efficiency of markets, data is critical,” said Haje Schutte, a deputy director at the OECD. “There is an ethical and fairness dimension to that. The public sector institutions have a role to beyond their institutional self-interests.”
US climate envoy says work will continue despite Trump’s return
Some development banks are worried about sharing their proprietary information and require the OECD to sign non-disclosure agreements, Schutte said.
Alert to the criticism and after an investor consultation, MDBs have increased the credit risk data shared in a database called Gems, originally designed to be used for information exchange between the banks themselves.
Since March, some data on recovery rates for public and private lending has been made available and in October more historic data was offered. But some investors are demanding more granular risk information.
Erich Cripton, a director at Canadian pension fund CDPQ Global, which has more than $300bn (R5.44-trillion) in assets under management, said investors have been pushing for MDBS to publish more data in the Gems database. He said the released data reflected the MDBs preferred creditor status, meaning that for a private investor, the risk was higher.
For Nadia Nikolova, lead portfolio manager at Allianz Global Investor, who has raised more than $3.5bn (R63.46bn) in development finance and affect credit strategies, the lack of information hampers her ability to raise and invest capital in developing economies.
“Institutional investors have a fiduciary duty to invest money responsibly,” she said. “If I don't have that information, I can't price the risk.”
Abdullahi Khalif, Somalia's chief climate negotiator, acknowledged on the sidelines of the COP29 talks that investing there was riskier than in industrialised economies, but said those who did so had opportunities for good returns in areas including renewable energy and irrigation.
“The only private sector that can come is a private sector that is really looking forward to taking the risk,” said Khalif.
Reuters
READ MORE:
Inequality is global threat to economic growth and stability: Ramaphosa
Brazil's first lady insults Elon Musk at G20 social event
EXPLAINER | How methane emissions threaten climate goals
Current climate pledges fall way short on Paris goals, UN body says
Climate change worsened rain in flood-hit African regions: scientists
UK development bank brings in Brics bank ex-CFO Leslie Maasdorp as head
Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.
Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.
News and promos in your inbox
subscribeMost read
Latest Videos