5 reactions to Julius Malema's hate speech ruling
Social media users flooded Twitter timelines on Wednesday after the SA Human Rights Commission ruled that EFF leader Julius Malema's utterances were "problematic" but did not amount to hate speech.
The SAHRC's chairperson Bongani Majola said five complaints had been received against Malema between 2016 and 2018.
Majola said the commission considered the complaints, looking at the facts, context, the applicable law and the constitution in the process. It ruled that Malema's comments had not amounted to hate speech.
"We came to the conclusion that while the acts forming the subject of the complaints may be offensive, they do not meet the legal threshold to qualify as hate speech," Majola said.
"We took quite some time to consider these Malema matters, partly because the law itself in this regard is not yet crystal clear, and partly because we wanted to view and review the conclusions that the legal principals seemed to be compelling us towards."
The decision has been celebrated by many on social media. Social media users flooded Twitter with their reaction to the news.
There were five kinds of response:
Introducing the 'it’s not a hate speech dance'
Let me take this opportunity to introduce “it’s not a hate speech dance “ #SAHRC as we soldier on #OurLandAndJobsNow pic.twitter.com/Yb8FYuleGF
— Patrick Sindane (@sindane3) March 27, 2019
@Julius_S_Malema when he sees the #SAHRC Judgement. pic.twitter.com/ZSH2AR0KYO
— Mzi’ayifani (@S_Gwiliza) March 27, 2019
All the chest pains
On your marks. Get (up)set.... Chest pains #EFFHateSpeechFinding pic.twitter.com/1gLL18RXd3
— Deelee Mogale (@Deeleenquent) March 27, 2019
The @SAHRCommission findings on #EFFHateSpeechFinding is going to cause sphithiphithi on these streets and elsewhere pic.twitter.com/gRPV37zuTs
— Tumi Sole (@tumisole) March 27, 2019
Some people are going to need a hug today.#EFFHateSpeechFinding pic.twitter.com/gknf2NefK4
— Welile 'Wellington' G (@WelsWG) March 27, 2019
The man speaks truth
#SAHRC hate speech turns out to be the truth, people hate the truth.
— Dr Maupanaga🇿🇦🇳🇬 (@Kwena_phoka) March 27, 2019
Malema speaks the uncomfortable speech. pic.twitter.com/TOiA55QvI6
#JuliusMalema #SAHRC #EFFHateSpeechFinding hate him or love him the man is a true born leader, y'all can what ever you want about him but deep down in your hearts you know the truth. The man has made us realize that no white or Indian person is better than us African people pic.twitter.com/17MbXzpl5o
— I AM AN AFRICAN (@MafambaT) March 27, 2019
Who complained in the first place?
#EFFHateSpeechFinding who reported Our CIC kanti vele😂😂😂 pic.twitter.com/GKO3RSxV6e
— 🇿🇦🏳🌈Sphamandla Lawrence (@_SphamandlaM) March 27, 2019
Nobody collects Ls like an enemy of the EFF.
— Welile 'Wellington' G (@WelsWG) March 27, 2019
They are now saying the Human Rights Commission is useless.#EFFHateSpeechFinding pic.twitter.com/jJ6wsoooGX
#EFFHateSpeechFinding
— nalediwithbeard (@nalediwithbeard) March 27, 2019
SAHRC concludes, black people can't be racist . pic.twitter.com/23WPbgXGov
Now for the elections
#EFFHateSpeechFinding now let’s walk in peace to parliament on the 8th May. The truth is very painful pic.twitter.com/u7cJVo1sqf
— Tsapi Wa Mofokeng 🐇 (@ItumelengTsapi) March 27, 2019