SA’s new agricultural leadership should focus on getting things done, not designing new policies

The DA’s agricultural approach is no different from the ANC’s

03 July 2024 - 21:28 By Wandile Sihlobo
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
Farm workers harvest grapes at the Diemersfontein Wine and Country Estate in Wellington in the Western Cape. File photo.
Farm workers harvest grapes at the Diemersfontein Wine and Country Estate in Wellington in the Western Cape. File photo.
Image: Esa Alexander

South Africa’s primary agriculture sector accounts for nearly 3% of GDP and about 8% when considering the value of agro-processing. But it can contribute even more to economic growth that delivers benefits fairly across society and creates jobs.

This can’t happen, however, if new policies and plans keep getting introduced. Fortunately, the views of the new agricultural minister, John Steenhuisen, may not be far from the existing policy path. Steenhuisen is the leader of the DA, the second-biggest party in parliament, which has joined a unity government with the ANC after the latter failed to win the majority vote.

The ANC  has been governing under the vision of the National Development Plan, which was recently distilled into the Agriculture and Agro-processing Master Plan. The aim is to grow an inclusive and competitive agricultural economy by focusing on specific commodities and their value chains, as well as specific regions.

The DA's agricultural approach is no different from the ANC’s. For example, in its 2024 manifesto, the DA states that the party will “empower South Africans through land ownership by protecting private ownership of land as outlined in section 25 of the constitution”.

It also promised to utilise government-owned land and prioritise the use of land owned by the government, specifically focusing on the vast tracts held by the departments of agriculture, forestry and fisheries, as well as public works and infrastructure.

The DA says it will improve post-settlement support to beneficiaries of land reform by strengthening the capacity of provincial governments. Post-settlement support refers to the assistance that government gives new land owners.

The major political parties’ views are aligned. And South Africa already has good policies that can ensure agriculture’s potential is realised. Therefore the task of the new political leadership should be relentless implementation.

The main programme of action is the Agriculture and Agro-processing Master Plan, which was co-created in 2022 by business, labour, government and social partners. The implementation of the plan so far has been scant, but major stakeholders in the sector remain enthusiastic about it. Also missing is a good understanding of the plan by officials in provincial and local government. This is key because they are the ones who must work with the private sector to carry out the master plan.

There are several other factors holding back agriculture’s development and growth. They fall outside the department of agriculture’s control but are key to the sector’s functioning as they either increase operating costs or turn off further investment. Much of the master plan’s success depends on these factors being addressed. For example, if a municipality is not delivering services and roads are poorly maintained, it is tough to attract investment.

The major priorities for the new minister, which would have much wider positive spin-offs for the sector, would be the following aspects of the master plan.

The priorities

Animal health: the former agriculture minister, Thoko Didiza, appointed a Ministerial Special Task Team to provide insight on ways to improve animal health in South Africa. The team’s report provides clear policy guidelines, which the new administration should follow. The livestock and poultry subsector forms nearly half of the South African agricultural economy. This makes animal health vital, especially for the export drive that is a focus in the sector.

Agricultural product standards: there have been various complaints in the industry about the use and high costs of private sector inspectors to ensure agricultural products meet set standards. The next administration should address this, as costs burden producers and consumers. In some cases, it’s not clear what benefits some of these private sector inspectors bring to the industry.

Registrar for Act 36: government, academia and organised agriculture are doing work to improve the capacity and effectiveness of this crucial office, which registers all new agrochemicals, seeds and other agricultural products. The initiatives under way must continue under the new administration. Delays and backlogs in the registrar’s office must be cleared.

Agricultural exports: the South African government has done admirable work opening export markets over the years. These efforts should continue to focus on India, China, Saudi Arabia and Egypt, among others. Existing markets in Africa, the EU, the Americas, parts of Asia and the Middle East must also be nurtured. South Africa needs as many export markets as possible to improve diversification in a world of geopolitical tensions.

Statistics: the agriculture department should improve the statistics on agriculture across all subsectors. These are critical for monitoring, evaluation and policy formulation. There are gaps in understanding smallholder and informal value chains, partly because of inadequate statistics.

The agriculture department must work with other departments on:

  • Ports and rail: critical to exports and domestic product distribution.
  • Roads and municipalities: vital for the success of agriculture and agribusinesses.
  • Rural crime: stock theft and other forms of crime undermine investment in agriculture and the growth of small towns.
  • Water: collaboration with the department of water affairs and others to improve the policy dispensation on irrigation water.
  • Land reform: the land reform and rural development department, which is now under another minister, should continue setting up the Land Reform and Agricultural Development Agency. The agency’s main task is to release about 2.5-million hectares of land held by the state to intended beneficiaries. This transfer can potentially improve the inclusiveness and growth of the agricultural sector. The land release process will need various agencies to collaborate.

Agriculture is a sector that can uplift the economic conditions of rural South Africa, and provide much-needed jobs. Leaders at both departments of agriculture and land reform must build on the existing work.

Wandile Sihlobo is Senior Fellow, Department of Agricultural Economics, Stellenbosch University. He is also the chief economist of the Agricultural Business Chamber of South Africa (Agbiz) and a member of the Presidential Economic Advisory Council.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence. Read the original article.

subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now

Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.