How to make the ultimate French toast

You might think French toast is a trifling matter but I’d like to persuade you otherwise. The big thing with food (and life in general) right now is the extremely tricky act of Not Wasting. Most households have bread in them and much of it gets chucked out. This we know. So, a dish which uses leftover bread is a most magnificent thing. And it’s especially magical when its starting point is so humble.

French toast is certainly a modest sort of dish, being created from leftovers and all. Like French kissing, but unlike French knickers, it doesn’t actually owe its invention to the French. The Romans were the first recorded toasters. They tore bread into pieces before soaking it in a milk-egg mix, fried it in olive oil, and poured honey over it. Quite a posh Roman’s leftovers, really.

Apicius, who recorded the recipe, asks for further luxury in that the crusts should be cut off. Bit wasteful, eh? The French names pain perduor “lost bread”, and the German arme ritter, the same as the English “poor knights”, point more to austerity and make-do. But nowadays the trend – doubtless fuelled by Instagram and bloggers – is towards eggy bread with very lofty ambitions, more in keeping with the Romans.

Indulgent additions and toppings are cool, sure, but going berserk in that department doesn’t help if the basics aren’t right. Follow these four suggestions – okay draconian rules – and you might find it’s like eating the dish for the very first time.    

1. PICK THE RIGHT BREAD

First of all – obvious but usually ignored - the bread you use is the alpha and omega of things. In fact, making French toast is an object lesson in industrial versus real bread.

There’s no way you can use industrial loaf here. The added gluten and improver, plus the whipped-in air, always reveal themselves when this kind of bread hits moisture. You’ll be making French mush, not French toast.

A properly made bread, with its strong structure and developed (though not added) gluten, doesn’t dissolve into gloop when soaked. And soaking is what’s needed.  

2. DON'T DIP AND GO

That’s the second big thing. No “dip and go”, please. Never. The bread (which should be sliced thickly) must be left in the egg mix until soaked right through to the centre. I’m talking 10 minutes or more.

3. MAKE IT CREAMY

Third thing - the egg-milk mix. Only use full-cream milk; around 1 cup to three or four eggs.

And if you’re making a sweet version, scenting the mix with cinnamon, nutmeg and vanilla is not the worst idea anyone ever had.

4. BUTTER, BUTTER, BUTTER!

Fourth - and here I part with the Romans, pathetically fond as I am of them – fry in generous butter. Not oil and not margarine. And, no, “butter spread” is not butter, it’s pure evil.

Fry on a low heat until golden-brown and eat posthaste. Rolling in cinnamon-sugar while piping hot creates a French toast doughnut which is utter bliss.

• This article was originally published on Wanted Online. Wanted is a luxury lifestyle magazine available to Business Day subscribers.