Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 40952.31
    DOWN -1.11%
    Top 40 : 3316.52
    DOWN -1.10%
    Financial 15 : 11830.82
    DOWN -2.19%
    Industrial 25 : 46771.02
    DOWN -0.85%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.4556
    UP 0.59%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3740
    UP 1.06%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.1449
    UP 2.47%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0922
    UP 0.93%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2368
    UP 0.83%

  • Gold : 1356.2230
    UP 0.97%
    Platinum : 1451.0000
    UP 1.54%
    Silver : 21.6573
    UP 2.85%
    Palladium : 738.5000
    UP 0.61%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.270
    DOWN -0.33%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Mon May 20 15:44:47 SAST 2013

Juju's Jackpot

Stephan Hofstatter, Mzilikazi Wa Afrika and Rob Rose | 19 May, 2012 23:57
JULIUS MALEMA

Limpopo tenderpreneurs who benefited from dodgy government deals splashed out millions to secretly buy the former ANC Youth League leader, Julius Malema, a R3.9-million farm near Polokwane.

These and other sensational revelations are contained in a damning PricewaterhouseCoopers audit into Malema's financial affairs, prepared for the National Treasury and seen by the Sunday Times.

The audit puts Malema at the centre of a web of dubious payments and dodgy tenders that were rigged to go to his friends' companies, in return for what appear to be generous kickbacks paid into his family trust account, which he used as his personal piggy bank.

Bank statements show that Malema's Ratanang Family Trust received R7.6-million over 36 months. Despite Malema's claims these were "donations" for charitable causes, he withdrew R5.7-million of that with 168 cheques, mostly made out to cash for "round amounts" of up to R200000.

"This is a very unusual practice, especially when one takes into account the fact that this is the bank account of a trust and not Mr Malema's personal account," the audit concludes.

An analysis of the bank statements also confirms that Tokyo Sexwale's Mvelaphanda Holdings paid R100000 to Ratanang , on December 22 2010.

It is clear from the audit that Malema and his business associate Lesiba Gwangwa milked Limpopo's R4.6-billion roads budget through tenders awarded to their cronies through their company, On-Point Engineers.

His rags-to-riches story began when the Limpopo government, headed by Malema's friend, premier Cassel Mathale, awarded On-Point a R52-million deal to manage its R4.6-billion roads budget in September 2009.

New revelations contained in hundreds of documents including cheques, bank statements and tender documents seen by the Sunday Times include:

On-Point, in which Malema indirectly owns shares, won the R52-million "project management" tender ahead of 15 other bidders even though it lied about its expertise and experience, submitted a tax certificate under the wrong name, and was almost three times more expensive than a rival bidder. This put the company in a position to dole out tenders to Malema's friends in return for kickbacks;

Companies that scored lucrative Limpopo tenders, including On-Point and Mpotseng Infrastructure, paid R2-million towards buying Malema the farm Schuilkraal near Polokwane. Another R1-million was paid towards the farm by Oceansite Trading 777, which won a road maintenance tender worth R6.2-million with On-Point's help;

On-Point paid R1.2-million to Ratanang's bank account in 12 payments as "dividends" Malema claims were due to him as 50% shareholder of Guilder 59, which owns a third of On-Point; and

Another R6.4-million was paid into the trust in cash deposits or electronic transfers ranging from R10000 to R250000, including R100000 from Sexwale's Mvelaphanda Holdings.

In an interview with the Sunday Times this week, Malema denied that he used Ratanang Trust as a personal bank, and laundered money that came from On-Point

"Yes, a lot of money came into Ratanang, it was never a secret ... I can give every specific explanation to law enforcement, not to you. I refuse to account to the minorities," he said.

Last week at a press conference, Malema said unequivocally: "I have not received any money from comrade Tokyo. I wish I had received some money." Confronted with the bank statement analysis, Malema backtracked: "I've never said that Mvela paid me, or did not pay me. The point I made is that I was never bought by Tokyo to support him for president. I always said Ratanang received donations from different good Samaritans." He refused to confirm the identity of those donors.

Malema said he did not need to reveal who gave money to Ratanang because it "did not receive money from any public institution. Ratanang received money from individuals who gave it out of their own goodwill, nobody put a gun to their head."

This is contradicted by the audit, which traces payments for roads tenders that landed up in Malema's pocket.

The audit focuses on three shady tenders, worth about R60-million, that Limpopo's roads department awarded to On-Point Engineers, Mpotseng Infrastructure and Oceansite, and the kickbacks that these companies made to the trust.

All three companies are linked to Malema. Mpotseng is headed by Arthur Mpotseng Pethla, who was Gwangwa's co-director in On-Point, while Oceansite is headed by Helen Moreroa, who is married to Selby Manthata. Manthata, who also reportedly scored a R19-million roads tender from On-Point, is a business partner of Malema's friend, premier Mathale.

With On-Point running Limpopo's roads department's projects, it could influence who got tenders and even authorise payment of invoices. The audit shows that On-Point authorised payments to Mpotseng, while an On-Point shareholder, Tshiamo Ditchabe, sat on the bid evaluation committee that awarded Oceansite its tender.

The purchase of Malema's farm was the most blatant example of a kickback for these services.

On March 22 2011, Malema signed a deed of sale for Ratanang to buy the farm for R3.9-million from Andries and Jennifer Kotze. Four payments of about R1-million each were due to be paid over four months from April to July to the "transferring attorneys Kampherbeek, Twine & Pogrund".

The audit shows that in May 2011, on the day Mpotseng received its last payment from the roads department for a R2.5-million tender, it paid R1-million to On-Point. A week later, this R1-million was paid to Kampherbeek, Twine & Pogrund with the payment description "Ratanang Farm".

In June 2011, On-Point paid another R1-million directly for the farm. Oceansite also paid R1-million to the lawyers for the farm, and a company called Qualis Health and Safety Consultants paid the outstanding balance of R986418 on July 8 2011.

"It is clear, based on the flow of funds, that after receiving payments from the department, [Mpotseng and Oceansite] made payments for the ultimate benefit of the Ratanang Trust, and that in the case of Mpotseng the payment was routed via On-Point Engineers," the audit states.

The documents show that Malema, who was under intense media scrutiny at the time, then tried to shift the farm into the name of Gwama Properties, run by his close friend Gwangwa.

On July 26, Malema signed a "cancellation agreement" with the Kotzes for the farm. Two days later, Gwama Properties signed a deed of sale to buy Schuilkraal from the Kotzes for R3.9-million.

A week later, on August 2, Malema sent an instruction to Kampherbeek to "transfer the funds in their trust account, being held on behalf of [Ratanang] to the account of Gwama Properties".

In the interview, Malema was adamant that neither he nor Ratanang had bought Schuilkraal, but he refused to explain why he signed the purchase agreement, then cancelled it, or why money given to his trust was used to pay for the farm.

"I've never bought a farm, and that's where I'm prepared to go on this matter ... I'm not going to answer the way you want me to answer," he said.

Gwangwa initially offered to respond in writing through his lawyer, Mpoyana Ledwaba, but after receiving detailed questions told the Sunday Times: "I refuse to speak to journalists."

After asking the Sunday Times to e-mail him questions, Phetla's lawyer, Mojalefa Motalane, said: "We really don't have any answers. The payments that you are asking us about are part of an ongoing investigation and my client is cooperating with the relevant law enforcement agencies."

Moreroa denied any knowledge of chipping in R1-million towards Malema's farm, then failed to return calls after being e-mailed a cheque proving the payment.

Asked why the Limpopo roads department had clearly tailor-made the tender to suit On-Point, spokesman Joshua Kwapa said the allegations were being investigated by the Treasury, the Hawks and the public protector. "It would be jumping the gun to comment in detail at this stage." If the tender was found to be unlawful, the department would take action which could include recovering the funds paid to On-Point.

investigations@sundaytimes.co.za

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Voiceofreason#1

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
"We want to live the same lifestyle like they (whites) live"
"They (whites) stole our land and minerals"
"We are poor"
"When a black man does well questions are asked"
etc, etc, etc......

Nothing but shameful Mr Malema.
Avatar

tsilim

Posted 364 days ago
It's bad to get wealth from bribes.
We are being taxed for our income, and there so called politicians will come and chow states money illegally.
I think that SARS, Hawks, Public protector are delaying to investigate this guy. For daily we receive illegal crimes coming from the same individual. It really makes me sick.
Avatar

AfricansUniteAgainst_

Posted 364 days ago
but you would cry if bread companies colluded to take bread away from the poor.why do some people only complain about ANC/government immorality but never about private sector corruption and immorality?
Avatar

LethaboMokoena

Posted 362 days ago
whts shocking abt anc memembers,mxm

HermanBrummer

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Wow, from the same guy that claimed:
1 - he supported the poor,
2 - that he himself was poor,
3 - that he has never seen a million rand,
4 - that the money from the trust was used to uplift the poor,
5 - that he never received money from the companies SLG and On-Point
6 - that he was never involved in business,
7 - that he did not get money from Sexwale
8 - that he never interfered with tenders processes.

WAKE UP SA, this is the TIP OF ICE BERG!!! ZUMA has got just as much, if not more wrong!




JacquesKirchner

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Somehow I think we have only seen the tip of the iceberg here. Apparently he owes SARS 15 million being kicked out of the ANC does not mean no income for this guy. He IS the ANC thus people will still pay him to be associated with him.

BUDDYC

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
...and when Malema said he is champion of the poor, that does not mean the requirements of being champion of the poor are that one has to be poor too, otherwise people won't take you serious or even believe what you say. So Julius Malema has to be rich so that he becomes relevant. Now the story you just told us is one of those many many stories that seeks to make the public think Julius is wrong and will be arrested soon, yet nothing is coming out. How long did the investigation go? People are looking for a political way to arrest Julius and i'm happy he welcomed investigation and now is just dragging on and on... Public protector investigated Julius in 2010 and nothing came out and so what is she doing differnently now?
Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
Buddyc, am sorry but I don't understand you're point. why can't you just wait until all the investigations are completed and see what comes out and stop thinking that every time something is said about Julias "it's a political way of arresting him" so you want to tell me that if he's found to be guilty in the court of law it will also be a political way of incarcerating him? come on please!
Avatar

kholofelo.madihlaba

Posted 364 days ago
Buddyc you sound bitter because of this Audit Engagement findings, you are the 1st person i have ever heard oppossing Audit findings.

SenzoM

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Ya, the champion of the poor.

Unbelievable stuff. I wish people would see the light and stop supporting crooks by voting for them.

Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
Who can we vote for if not ANC? I don't see my self voting DA..and there's no other black led party that is doing well. So does that mean I must sit at home or go shopping on the elections day? Aowa! I'll keep voting ANC ..things will be fine one day. Yes Juju and many others are crooks but the good thing in this country is that we have what is called law and the rights to use it under any circumstance..even him Juju he know that he's in trouble
Avatar

ER2

Posted 365 days ago
@Ceaser

If your only choice for whom you can vote is the ANC , don't vote.

BUDDYC

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Julius Malema is not wrong nor corrupt...otherwise he would have long being arrested by now. People who want second term are all behind this. Since 2010 the media has been telling us that Malema is to be arrested, now i think all these stories are sponsored. Why no court about his finances and where is the arrest that we were promised we will see soon? People must stop reporting to us what they wish to happen on the young lion rather the right information. To be champion of the poor does not mean you have to be poor.
Avatar

a_stub_born

Posted 365 days ago
....if he would be arrested now. you would be screaming : "Innocent until proven guilty"".....would you not?......
Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
So you are saying all the audits are tailor made to make him look corrupt or wrong? It does not matter how long the investigation takes..fact is the truth must come out and justice must prevail. He is not God..if he is found guilty he must serve his time....

SenzoM

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Yes Ceaser, things will be fine one day just like they are fine in Zimbabwe and the rest of Africa.
Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
Let's be realistic our constitution is the best compared to the rest of Africa..that's why you see people depicting the private parts of the president hiding behind the same constitution...so unless it changes then we should worry. If someone tells me who to vote and why I will definitely consider not giving my vote to the ANC in the next election..but Zille is not an option..I can't even talk about COPE.
Avatar

Remote

Posted 365 days ago
Ceaser

"....not giving my vote to the ANC in the next election..but Zille is not an option..."



Why not? We keep on reading your comments on how the DA and Zille is not an option.


Please elaborate
Avatar

viCBangamwabo

Posted 364 days ago
@ Ceaser, oh trust me you may think that the SA constitution can't be changed but the corrupt individuals within the ANC will try by all means to change whatever law in order to carry on their corrupt ways or hide their involvement. Should we start discussing about the secrecy bill, how about the medical paroles guys like Shabir Shaik and Selebi had been getting or reduced sentencing, and why is it that an average criminal could never get such treatment?! I though SA justice is based on the law outlined by the very firm constitution. And then, all of a sudden on freedom day, some criminals/inmates who have not committed "aggressive crimes" are pardoned by the president. Really! Wasn't the disbanding of the scorpion unconstitutional? All I can say is that we're slowly sliding worse state, and make no mistake, corruption levels you have in countries like Nigeria and Ghana (amongst other African countries) started off small and insignificant. Am sure some people lived on hope that things will be fine one day.

a_stub_born

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
........and why would the "Island sole owner" Sexwale risk to burn his fingers with this piece of hot burning manure ?????...........
Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
Well maybe am emotionally attached to Black led political parties and this does not make me a racist..am just scared that I will experience the same hardship I went through before 1994..when a group of young white boys attacked me and called me all sorts of derogatory names without provoking them..and other white people just drove and walked passed without helping me. So am really worried about my kids hey..I don't want to some day blame my self for not protecting them with my vote...because that's the only why to protect a black person from that harsh situation....every time I look at my kids and say to myself I will do anything to protect them..and that means from my black brothers who break into our houses and rob us and from the atrocities that I have personally suffered during apartheid era.
Avatar

Remote

Posted 365 days ago

Ceaser

"..Well maybe am emotionally attached to Black led political parties...."

Emotions should never become part of politics. You choose your wife with emotions , not your government. Guess who has been screwing whom since 1994..

"...and this does not make me a racist.."

Actually it does. You have decided that a so-called "black led" party will do a better job than a party wrongly or rightly associated with "white leadership"

rac·ism/ˈrāˌsizəm/
Noun: 1.The belief that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, esp. so as to distinguish it as...
2. Prejudice or discrimination directed against someone of a different race based on such a belief.




"...I am just scared that I will experience the same hardship I went through before 1994.."

Which is understandable. But you are presuming that pre-1994 was a paradise for the white people of this country. And now they have the same fears you had then.

And by virtue of your vote you can either perpetuate these fears from both sides , or change lanes and look for a way out of this political rut this country finds itself here today.

Avatar

KALSTER

Posted 364 days ago
@Ceaser

"Well maybe am emotionally attached to Black led political parties and this does not make me a racist..am just scared that I will experience the same hardship I went through before 1994..when a group of young white boys attacked me and called me all sorts of derogatory names without provoking them..and other white people just drove and walked passed without helping me"

I can certainly sympathise with this. I can never fully comprehend the oppression you must have suffered. As an Afrikaner white person, I am sorely ashamed of the conduct of some of my fellows and the apartheid government. But we live in the new South Africa now. While racism will never be dealt with overnight and will never be completely gone, my experience is that we are slowly but surely shedding some of this inane, ignorant nonsense. My children will NOT grow up as racists. But, it is still a prevalent cancer among many flavours of South Africans today.

As to not voting for the DA: Surely now is the time to stop acting out of fear and instead acting pro-actively towards a better future for ALL of us? As long as you hold on to that fear, you will never be rid of it. You are in effect still being oppressed, only now it is by your own mind. It is time to break free. Don't let your children suffer under the same legacy. Make a new one.
I don't see the DA as a white party and that is certainly not why I vote for them. They have many black leaders that fly the flag of racial freedom quite happily. They certainly have a good record in the Western Cape, though no party can be perfect.

Paraphrasing what Gandi said:" Be the change you want to see in the word". Now is the time to act as a South African citizen, not as a member of a specific racial group. We are one! I know it sounds corny, but that doesn't make it untrue. Good luck to you.

a_stub_born

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
""""Let's be realistic our constitution is the best compared to the rest of Africa..that's why you see people depicting the private parts of the president hiding behind the same constitution"""""""

........Then in that case, the US Constitution is even better, because it allowed the impeachment of Nixon, and the attempt of getting rid of Clinton thanks to his "sshhmoking" abilities......

Constitution only works when put into practice. When it is trampled by a diktatorship it ceases to be the Supreme Law and is worth less than a toilet paper roll.............
Avatar

Ceaser

Posted 365 days ago
100% but who can we trust with the task to ensure it's put into practice? I totally agree with you there...

Polony_Lips

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Oh the proverbial plot thickens around "pork chop"

l984

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar

Economic Freedom indeed.

GoneGonzo

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Can't believe we're still reading about this guy.

mfranco

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
Well done to Hofstatter, Wa Afrika and Rose.

My only complaint ?why? you had to use a picture of Mr. Malema wearing a military beret.
He was never a soldier.
He has no idea of what it takes to be a soldier.
He has not stood in harms way.
He has not the honour of a soldier toward his compatriots.
(Read "fire-brand")
He could not run a kilometre carrying 20 or 30 kilos of stuff. His physique belies his excesses.
He has shown he has No discipline, No sense of visionary leadership and No sense of winning over the otherside by the use of reason.
He bought all of this upon himself... Well Done!

the_original_MommaCyndi

Posted 365 days ago
Avatar
I have to wonder how much of this would have been hushed up if Malema supported Zuma and just how many other like incidences ARE being covered up.

Politics have always been a disgustingly murky business but SA seems to be taking it to whole new lows. That is the problem with young democracies. We don't understand just how important it is to have changes in government and a very strong opposition - although that is more the SA opposition's fault than anyone else's. Gods but our opposition parties are sad.
Avatar

Scribbles

Posted 364 days ago
Considering the abominable monster which the ANC has become, I believe that the voters should shoulder most of the blame and not alternative political parties..

Seriously, if Zuma gets a second term and the population still votes for the ANC then I'm just going to say "F*** it!" Drop politics and enjoy South Africa right until it's run into the ground.
Avatar

uitlander

Posted 342 days ago
JM is young and impatient - he should have just waited for the Suppresion of Information bill and he could have bought a string of farms. it would take him a lifeime tyo ruin them.