• All Share : 53734.0357
    DOWN -0.97%
    Top40 - (Tradeable) : 47491.8711
    DOWN -1.07%
    Financial 15 : 17714.9138
    DOWN -0.55%
    Industrial 25 : 68254.549
    DOWN -1.19%
    Resource 10 : 40963.7701
    DOWN -1.11%

  • ZAR/USD : 12.0675
    UP 0.94%
    ZAR/GBP : 18.0192
    UP 0.01%
    ZAR/EUR : 13.0357
    UP 0.06%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.101
    UP 1.10%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.3809

  • Gold US$/oz : 1199.25
    Platinum US$/oz : 1159.25
    Silver US$/oz : 16.31
    Palladium US$/oz : 780.5
    Brent Crude : 63.71

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by Profile Data
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Sun Apr 19 21:06:46 SAST 2015

Government stifling debate by attacking business critics

The Times Editorial | 23 January, 2013 00:02

The Times Editorial: First National Bank has been bullied by the ANC to withdraw parts of its You Can Help advertising campaign featuring schoolchildren appealing to their countrymen to work together for a betterSouth Africa.

The advert is controversial in part - some of the youngsters read scripted messages criticising the failings of the government, notably in education - but it is hardly treasonous, as the ANC Youth League puts it.

In 2007, an arguably naive FNB was forced to pull a multimillion-rand campaign in which it intended to write to then President Thabo Mbeki urging him to prioritise the fight against crime.

The anti-crime campaign was relevant and truthful - criminality was rampant five years ago and just about every citizen was affected by it - and it is a great pity that FNB had to can it.

The withdrawal of parts of the latest campaign is equally unfortunate.

Once again the space for a necessary debate about the state of South Africa - as seen by the country's future, its children - has been compromised so as not to upset the ruling party further.

Business has been thumped on the head an awful lot by the ruling party of late for speaking its mind. Remember how Reuel Khoza, the chairman of Nedbank, was savaged last year for using the bank's annual report to criticise the quality of our political leadership?

It goes without saying that the ANC and the government are too sensitive about constructive criticism. In a developing democracy, robust debate and, where necessary, criticism of the powerful, should be encouraged, not squashed.

But the latest uproar, coming hot on the heels of the Amplats controversy, in which the mineral resources minister threatened to review Anglo-American's mining rights, also speaks volumes about the suspicion with which the ruling party regards big business.


If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.