Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE &
Business LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
Thu Feb 23 07:58:21 SAST 2012

Enoch Godongwana's shock resignation

Philani Nombembe | 16 January, 2012 00:05

The shock resignation of Enoch Godongwana, deputy minister of economic development, was announced yesterday against the backdrop of an inquiry into the disappearance of millions of rands from the SA Clothing and Textile Workers' Union pension fund.

Mac Maharaj, spokesman for the Presidency, said yesterday that Godongwana, had resigned "to pursue personal interests".

Maharaj said Godongwana had informed President Jacob Zuma of "his intention early in December and the President asked him to stay on until mid-January".

Godongwana and his wife, Thandiwe, have been embroiled in a multimillion-rand scandal involving the union.

Thandiwe Godongwana, a director of Canyon Springs, is accused of borrowing R93-million from Trilinear Capital, which manages five provident funds for Sactwu. Much of the cash was paid over by Trilinear before a loan agreement was signed.

Canyon Springs were meant to repay the loan within three years but did not, leaving 15000 Sactwu members without pensions.

Godongwana has maintained that, when he joined Zuma's cabinet in 2009, he resigned from Pan African Benefits Services, Iboma Call Centre and Iboma Properties, beneficiaries of R27-million in loans from Canyon Springs.

In July last year the Sunday Times published information from Canyon Springs bank statements that showed:

  • Enoch Godongwana is listed as a recipient of payments ranging from R132000 to R83000 between December 2007 and August 2008;
  • Thandiwe Godongwana is listed as having received payments ranging from R12000 to R65000 between June 2009 and April 2010; and
  • Former Numsa general-secretary Silumko Nondwangu, who replaced Godongwana at the metal workers' union, received five R40000 payments between June and September 2009.

The Cape High Court granted a provisional liquidation against Canyon Springs last June.

The couple appeared before the inquiry last September and will appear again on January 27.

In December, Richard Kawie, a former union consultant, and Trilinear director Sam Buthelezi were arrested on allegations that they had "embezzled millions of rands linked to the clothing industry".

Kawie appeared before the inquiry in November after both men launched several court actions, apparently to avoid testifying. They spent Christmas in prison as they could not raise the R500000 bail.

On Thursday, Kawie paid R50000 cash and put up his properties in Goodwood, Cape Town and Noordhoek as guarantees for the remaining R450000. Buthelezi, who is expected to appear before the inquiry on January 30, is still in jail.

Tony Canny, the union's counsel, said they would stop at nothing to get him to testify.

"We've already spoken to the police to make an arrangement for him [Buthelezi] to be examined whether it is at Pollsmoor Prison or whether they actually bring him along to the inquiry," said Canny. "We don't think that will prevent us examining him."

At the time of their arrest, police said they had sensitive documentation indicating that Kawie had allegedly committed tax-related fraud of R942838. Buthelezi allegedly siphoned money from an empowerment trust into his account and paid creditors not linked to the group of companies. He is alleged to have stolen R15-million from the trust and its assets. Both men will appear in court in June.

Godongwana said yesterday his resignation had nothing to do with his business interests. "People can have their own opinions about my resignation but in my discussion with the ANC leadership and the Presidency, I did not talk about my business interests.

"It was out of my own assessment that I decided to resign. I realise that my hands would be full of party work this year."

Pressed to elaborate on his "party work'', Godongwana declined.

Zuma said he believed Godongwana's "work experience and expertise will not be entirely lost to the public service but will be utilised elsewhere in the pursuit of the goal of meaningful economic transformation".

In 2008 Godongwana, a former MEC for Economic Affairs in the Eastern Cape, was considered the frontrunner to be deputy finance minister to Pravin Gordhan.

In 2005 Godongwana was embroiled in another scandal when then Eastern Cape premier Nosimo Balindlela announced an inquiry to probe corruption and maladministration in the province.

Godongwana, with former premier Makhenkesi Stofile, Eastern Cape finance, economic development and environmental affairs MEC Mcebisi Jonas and ANC provincial chairman Stone Sizani, were implicated in the findings of the Pillay Commission, chaired by Judge Ronnie Pillay.

In 2009 the four had brought a high court application to have the Pillay findings dismissed.

In May 2009, Judge Dylan Chetty declared the inquiry's findings a "nullity".

Kobus Marais, DA spokesman on Economic Development, said: "It is the right thing to do. We expected the deputy minister to resign a long time ago."

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

Mike123

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Another ANC criminal? Another ANC presidential candidate?
Avatar

Timbuktoo

Posted 37 days ago
Another FAILED CADRE from the "Jobs for Mates" program....

Yep.... my postings can be removed.... must be hurting someone, hense the removal...
Avatar

Mike123

Posted 37 days ago
@Timbuktoo: The truth is something most South Africans try desperately to avoid.

BornintheRSA

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
More than that, this (ex) public servant thinks the public are idiots. He clearly has no shame nor feelings for those who have lost out on pension benefits - perhaps they won't lose out directly as the tax payer will put it right.

We reserve the rights to our opinions Mr Godongwana !

"Godongwana said yesterday his resignation had nothing to do with his business interests. "People can have their own opinions about my resignation but in my discussion with the ANC leadership and the Presidency, I did not talk about my business interests."

Avatar

AntonBarnard

Posted 37 days ago
Well, perhaps he is right that there are many idiots in the public. After all, I am prepared to bet that most Sactwu members are also ANC voters. You can also be sure that, come the next election, those whose pension money has been plundered by another ANC cadre, will vote ANC again.

People get the government they deserve, and I personally would have no sympathy for a Sactwu-member who continues to vote ANC after those he voted for plundered his pension, even if he has to eat dog food during his retirement.

bis_k'hallawaya

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
"The President has accepted the resignation and thanked the deputy minister for his dedicated service and duty to his portfolio and to the National Executive in general", he said in a statement..._

"....President Jacob Zuma said Godongwana's work experience and expertise would not be entirely lost to the public but would be used elsewhere in pursuing the goal of meaningful economic transformation. --Additional reporting by Sapa""...(Mail&Guardian)

""President Jacob Zuma's nephew Khulubuse always manages to bounce back.

After he was ordered by the Pretoria High Court on Wednesday to pay more than R10-million to Protea Coin Group, a creditor of his mining group Aurora Empowerment Systems, it emerged that two of his other companies, registered in the British Virgin Islands, have started a multi-billion-rand oil exploration project in the Democratic Republic of Congo....""


""""Spineless sheeple DESERVE to be fleeced
Ben Trovato | 15 January, 2012
WITH the podium awash in cake and catharsis, deputy president Kgalema Motlanthe raised his glass and proposed a toast. "The leaders will now enjoy the champagne, and of course they do so on your behalf through their lips." Later, the leadership drove off in luxury cars on behalf of those who had no transport and stayed in expensive hotels on behalf of those who lived in shacks. Welcome to the year of living vicariously....."""""'

.....2012 will be another "golden year" for the 'mafiosi' brothers in the organised crime syndicate in power.........

ScarfaceReturns

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Yes ENOCH IT HAS TO COME you did the right thing

ooooooooo

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
They have no shame at all. History will show that the ANC was the worst government in Africa by far.

ooooooooo

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Here we go again. The editor did not like the comments so he unilatterally remove them. Makes you wonder what is the point in having a comments column. I say again the ANC has no shame.

I984

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar

At this point it is impossible to keep track on the number of all those tainted individuals anymore, or on the number of all millions and billions gone missing.

It is actually hard to believe there can be still any money left in this country.

danny.archer1

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
What's this?? A cadre falling on his own sword?? Someone please check the temperature in hell!!

sancy4

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Why have COSATU, and more specifically Saint Tony (Ehrenreich) been so quiet regarding this mess?
Avatar

bis_k'hallawaya

Posted 37 days ago
....They are perfecting Mbeki's "quiet diplomacy".............

bis_k'hallawaya

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Mail&Guardian:

""""In October last year, Godongwana told a closed liquidation inquiry in Cape Town that he had expected to earn an annual salary of R1.5-million when he chaired Canyon Springs, but had been paid only when the company had money.

The company's books reveal that he received only R600 000 from Canyon Springs but, according to sources who attended the hearing, he said the company did not keep proper records.

From the records Canyon Springs did keep, it was apparently shown that Godongwana's salary was drawn from the clothing workers' pension money."""""""

....Definitely, another cadre who never joined the "struggle" to be poor........and COSATU is still in end-of-year holidays........

the_original_MommaCyndi

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Zuma said he believed Godongwana's "work experience and expertise will not be entirely lost to the public service but will be utilised elsewhere in the pursuit of the goal of meaningful economic transformation".


Oh my soul!
economic transformation of pensions from the legal owners to the back pocket is meaningful work experience?

1tsotsi

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
the choices of zuma have always been suspect, we expect more casualities. His the worse president the ANC has ever had, what a mistake of five years we had.

AnotherTaxPayer

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
We don't want your resignation. We want you convicted for fraud and sent to jail as an example of what happens to bribe takers and white (pink in this case) collar criminals. We'll be watching the trials carefully in June...

NeoBlack

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
Back to myopism. I thought 2012 will bring about some maturity, but i see folds are still locked up in their onw enclaves.
Compliments of the new year fellow racists.

bis-k'hallawaya

Posted 37 days ago
Avatar
....neo-same-stuff is correct: ANC politicians 2011 thievery, corruption and fraud is the same in 2012.........