Mbete and DA disagree over what to do about motion of no confidence in Zuma

12 April 2017 - 19:17 By Babalo Ndenze And Bianca Capazorio
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now

The debate on the motion of no confidence in President Jacob Zuma has become such a political hot potato that neither the Speaker of the National Assembly nor the leader of the Democratic Alliance wants to withdraw.

This comes after the United Democratic Movement’s (UDM) Bantu Holomisa threw a spanner in the works after asking the Constitutional Court to consider his application to rule whether the motion could be decided by a secret vote.

The court has asked all parties intending to oppose his application to file responding papers by no later than next Friday‚ April 21. This has led to calls for the no confidence vote‚ scheduled for Tuesday‚ April 18‚ to be postponed until the court has pronounced on the matter.

  • Birthday prayers of strength for Zuma in turbulent timesWhile others were calling for President Jacob Zuma's downfall‚ thousands joined in prayer for the opposite at Zuma's birthday celebration in Kliptown‚ Soweto on Wednesday. 

National Assembly Speaker Baleka Mbete and DA leader Mmusi Maimane‚ who has proposed the motion‚ were engaged in a day long toing-and-froing match over the issue on Wednesday with neither side prepared to relent.

Mbete insisted that the rules of the national assembly did not give her the authority to withdraw the motion while Maimane and his chief whip John Steenhuissen repeatedly emphasised that they were not asking for a withdrawal but rather a postponement.

  • I'm here to remind Zuma of his promises‚ says SACP councillorI'm here to remind Zuma of his promises‚ says SACP councillor 

Mbete could once more be subjected to intense criticism from within and outside the African National Congress (ANC) if she forges ahead with next week’s vote as doing so could be seen as her way of protecting Zuma in the absence of clarity on the secret ballot by the court.

Withdrawing it‚ on the other hand‚ would have cost implications for the legislature as flights have already been booked for close to 400 MPs after they were recalled from their Easter break.

Steenhuisen said "no one wants to withdraw the motion”. “We are simply asking that it be rescheduled‚” he said. Mbete had the power to do so in terms of rule 129‚ he added.

  • Zuma supporters muster for the President's birthday bashAs thousands of South Africans marched to the Union Buildings in Pretoria on Wednesday‚ African National Congress members from Pretoria made their way south to President Jacob Zuma's birthday bash. 

Steenhuisen said the DA was not willing to take the risk of withdrawing a motion already on the programme of parliament because it would then need to go through the whole process of approval and scheduling again.

He said that Parliament also had a duty to respect the judicial process.

  • WATCH: The People's Bae's rendition of Cape to Cairo will give you goosies!EFF spokesperson Mbuyiseni Ndlozi, aka 'The People's Bae', had thousands of protesters singing in unison on Wednesday when he led them in a spine-chilling rendition of the iconic struggle song Azania. 

"We're not talking of delaying it by months and months‚ the return date for the Constitutional Court is April 21‚" he said.

Mbete’s spokesman‚ Moloto Mothapo‚ cited a different rule to argue their case‚ saying a motion could only be withdrawn by its sponsor‚ not the Speaker‚ in terms of rule 128.

  • If Zuma adopted me‚ I would be happy: Zuma supporterA patch of blonde hair in a sea of black African supporters stood out in a crowd of ANC supporters who were in Kliptown‚ Soweto on Wednesday to celebrate the birthday of President Jacob Zuma. 

“The motion of no confidence‚ which the Speaker scheduled for April 18 at 2pm in the National Assembly‚ in line with the urgent request‚ is tabled under the name of the leader of the opposition‚ Mr Mmusi Maimane. Therefore‚ in terms of the provision in the Rules‚ only Mr Maimane - and not the Speaker - has the power to withdraw the motion‚” said Mothapo.

  • ‘If not wanting Zuma is racist‚ then we are proud racists’ - Malema"If not wanting Zuma is racist‚ then we are proud racists‚" EFF leader Julius Malema told an tens of thousands of marchers at the Union Buildings. 

UDM leader Bantu Holomisa accused Mbete of "playing tricks" and “delaying tactics" by trying to force a withdrawal. Holomisa said Mbete should engage with the DA.

Political analyst Ralph Mathekga said the apparent confusion showed how crucial the court decision was to the no confidence vote. “The court case is material to the motion‚” said Mathekga.

  • Who has broken ranks with Zuma?As opposition parties have come together to protest against the reign of President Jacob Zuma‚ a growing number of the ANC’s own have also come out to tell the President that it is perhaps time he heeded the call of the people. 

“The thing is it’s a procedural issue and you cannot in the country expedite any issue that the court is still waiting to act upon.”

TMG Digital/TimesLIVE

subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now