Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41504.26
    UP 1.03%
    Top 40 : 3406.67
    UP 1.96%
    Financial 15 : 11912.61
    UP 0.67%
    Industrial 25 : 47198.75
    UP 0.49%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5885
    UP 1.67%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.5315
    UP 0.92%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3319
    UP 1.37%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0933
    UP 1.03%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.3690
    UP 1.16%

  • Gold : 1381.3500
    DOWN -0.83%
    Platinum : 1468.0000
    DOWN -1.14%
    Silver : 22.6103
    DOWN -1.04%
    Palladium : 740.0000
    DOWN -0.40%
    Brent Crude Oil : 104.200
    DOWN -0.57%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Tue May 21 12:41:46 SAST 2013

Zuma's plan thrashed

AMUKELANI CHAUKE | 21 June, 2012 00:03
Kgalema Motlanthe. File photo.
Image by: Avusa

The ANC's second transition draft policy document punted by President Jacob Zuma is receiving mixed reaction from party structures.

On Wednesday, the ANC in North West joined Gauteng and Limpopo in rejecting the document. The Eastern Cape, which is to finalise its policy positions tomorrow, is said to have also rejected the document.

Though KwaZulu-Natal and Mpumalanga have endorsed the document, indications from ANC structures in other provinces, as well as within ANC alliance partner Cosatu, are that the policy proposal will be rejected when the ruling party holds its policy conference next week.

The ANC in Free State is yet to take a position on the party's policy proposals.

Earlier this month, Zuma told ANC delegates in Northern Cape that the apartheid economy remained intact and that a second transition to remove it was needed.

"We need a second transition because the first transition was relevant to the political transition. But it is not adequate for a social as well as economic transformation phase," he said.

But his deputy, Kgalema Motlanthe, last week punched holes into the proposal, which he said was loaded with "smatterings of Marxist jargon".

"Second transition! Second transition! Second transition! From what, from where to where? What constituted the first transition? What were the tasks of that phase; have all those tasks been accomplished or not?" Motlanthe asked.

The second transition draft document speaks of how the party focused on political transition in the first 18 years of democracy, and that the next 50 to 100 years should be dedicated to economic transition.

In rejecting it, the ANC in North West said the document created a notion that "there is a second transition that our struggle is entering as if there was a first transition declared at a given epoch of our struggle".

"This labelling of our current conjuncture of our history as the second transition further creates an impression that the first transition, as of the advent of democracy in 1994 to date, has resolved issues of inequality, racism, sexism, degradation, poverty, unemployment and landlessness," the province said in a statement.

Gauteng said the "concept is neither persuasive nor theoretically sound".

Limpopo has since said it does not agree with the separation of political and economic transformation.

The ANC Youth League has also rubbished the document, saying what was needed was a radical approach as prescribed in the Freedom Charter.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

BornintheRSA

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
This country desperately needs a second transition but not of the economy. The priority transition we need is one wherein children go back to school for a quality education which is globally recognised. Well-schooled youth will better able to find a place in any economy.
Avatar

DonaldKnight

Posted 334 days ago
Oh, and above all, what we need is a transition of power from one party to another...

SecretVoice

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Zuma's days are counted. The frightening thing is what comes after him. I don't think the ANC even knows. As an organization they have become so fragmented that it is impossible to know what their plans are.

Gormogon1

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
I am absolutely amazed at how deep the confusion and lack of leadership synergy runs within the ANC. They are really becoming a joke as a politically party. They are a rudderless one, who make decisions and formulate policy depending on how they feel that day.

Theye

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
"smatterings of Marxist jargon".
This is what bad and clueless leaders start spewing when they are lost at sea. If we are at the end of the first tranistion, whatever it was, we have failed miserably. The first transition hasd bee the rape of the countries purse and the attempted rape of our constitution

deebee

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
The ANC today resembles post-war Italy, where for 40 odd years they cobbled together any old lot that would feed at the same trough, regardless of ideology. The ANC is running a coalition government of Marxists, Black Nationalists, Trade Unionists, Tenderpreneurs, Arch capitalists and everything in between - the only glue in the system is a mutual love of wealth, power and the associated bling they can steal from the fiscus.

Don't get me wrong - there are good people in the ANC, they just don't seem to get to the top.
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 334 days ago
This is the best description of the ANC yet. Well done!!!
Avatar

nkosipeter

Posted 334 days ago
In real life the cream comes to the top, in the political world of the ANC it is the scum that surfaces.
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 334 days ago
"The ANC is running a coalition government of Marxists, Black Nationalists, Trade Unionists, Tenderpreneurs, Arch capitalists and everything in between - the only glue in the system is a mutual love of wealth, power and the associated bling they can steal from the fiscus.

Don't get me wrong - there are good people in the ANC, they just don't seem to get to the top. "

Agree 100% deebee, well put! Might add in staunch tribalists aswell !!

Those good people need to start making their voices heard for the sake of all the people of this country! They need to re-direct the focus of the leadership/ANC away from wealth, power and bling to true value adding service to the country and its people, upliftment of the nation, non-racialism, non-sexism, equality and tolerance. Hence providing a societal platform in which the people who have the abilities and motivation can grow and blossom.
They need to create(put back on the table) and impliment the dream of the majority of good citizens of RSA, that of good, fair, non-racial governance, free of corruption/nepotism/cronyism/tribalism/sexism/intolerance, with equal opportunities for all, in a sustainable, safe and caring socio-political enviroment.

Indeed, there is a LOT of work that needs to be done still!!!
Avatar

Tokolosh

Posted 334 days ago
This is so true!!
Avatar

odee

Posted 334 days ago
Well said deebee! Really nice. .

Ozgood

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Deebee - The good is of't interred with their bones
Avatar

Wiseguy

Posted 334 days ago
Yes, ozgood, unfortunately I feel and am ashamed you are probably correct.
Nevertheless, we as a nation, and the ANC as a political party, will not be and can never be dictated to by bullies !!!

If we let the bullies rule, we will never achieve fair governance, or a society the majority dream of......EVER !!!

The majority must take a stand against the bullies.....all bullies are cowards in their hearts, but that cowardice is only shown when the majority tell them to shut up and sit down!!

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
does this 'plan' have any real direction or is it simply the same old rhetoric?

I have never been fond of politicians who attempt to do social engineering as they simply have no clue. They seem to think that taking away from Peter to give to Paul is the answer when, in fact, the real answer is to get Paul off his backside and on the ladder upwards.

With a real unemployment rate of around 50%, half of the children being supported by government grants and half the population demanding houses with bullet proof toilets - a 'transition' is the least of our worries.

With the melt down of the Euro zone, we are in a perfect position to grow but we are completely wasting that chance by being side tracked by narrow political agendas

GermanMouser

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
ANC in KZN & Mpumalanga province lack leadership, they are puppet of Zuma, they are just like him desperate to remain in power, they agree with Zuma they don’t care whether he is wrong or using them. The two provinces are incompetent, in Mpumalanga people drinking water with animals and in KZN, everyday learners swim naked crossing the river just to go to school, they endorsed this stupid document so called second transition, Second Transition my foot…..
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 334 days ago
In our struggle against apartheid, we relied on some progressive comrades to oppose the IFP in the KZN, and were pleasantly surprised by this. But in Zuma the IFP goons have been attracted one of their 'uQonda', and simply migrated into it, leaving the IFP sinking ship.

But I believe that those real democrats are still opposed to the ethnic divide tactics that are being used now. As for Mpumalanga, I have never heard of an ANC there, except for the famous theft of state money, and unresolved deaths of any opponent of the elite.

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
The SACP has been running the ANC from its shadows since throughout its whole existence. Running the ANC propaganda through papers and books has ensured its survival for decades, because all its elite had to do was to 'think' for the ANC. When faced with complete death, its elite had to find a useless and and lame-duck person to propel to the ANC leadership. In Zuma they found a ideal dodo who could neither think nor do anything. All that was left was for the SACP elite to migrate to the ANC's control. But you cannot run a political party from a grave, without dragging it with you. After misleading and confusing him for most of his first term, he is now running for cover in places like Venezuela, but there are no holes to hide there, and he must come back and find a dark hole somewhere in a R64million. But that won't offer a sanctuary either, because the 'masses' he has been misleading, will dig him up there.

Its a pity that the SACP run ANC will wind up with the puppet they have installed in a hole - DEAD.

Afrojoy

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
"First...Second Transition"....sounds like Zanu PF mantra: 1st, 2nd, 3rd Chimurenga nonsense.

Mike123

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
Zuma! Get a wife... Oops! I mean life!

Black-Moses

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
We definitely need the 'second transition ' now...which is to get rid of all these ANC kleptomaniacs with smart technocrats, who will put the country first not their pockets.
Avatar

Maxi

Posted 333 days ago
Through the ballot box!!!

ProgressiveAfricanDemocrat

Posted 334 days ago
Avatar
What a rude awakening to Zuma factionalists and tribalists who were starting to believe their own lies. It is increasingly becoming clear that Jacob Zuma and Gwede Mantashe will find it difficult to win majority support in more than two provinces. KZN will probably go the Zuma since ANC members there are so mortified and fearful of Zuma factionalists, who will not allow any ANC branch to choose its preferred ANC leaders. Zuma factionalists in KZN are dictating to the ANC in KZN to vote as a block, which is simply mob psychology. They are afraid that if ANC branches are allowed free reign, many of them may not vote for Jacob Zuma. The ANC in Mpumalanga is definitely run by the Mafia, and it is about time that the ANC reclaimed. As it seems to be leaning towards Jacob Zuma, Gwede Mantashe and Jackson Mthembu (who hails from there by the way) are quiet happy with the status quo.

However, the rejection of the ill-conceived "second transition" by other provinces is a clear sign that Zuma and Mantashe are not going to have to have it their way. Zuma has hardly done justice to the "first transition" but he is already jumping to a fuzzy and wooly "second transition" that he himself cannot even explain, except to pitch it as his theme for re-election.

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 333 days ago
Avatar
LOL
Crazy Rori back again and off the medication.