Miners choose death over 'wage slavery'
Image by: Alon Skuy
As Lonmin yesterday re-issued its ultimatum to about 3000 striking rock-drillers at its Marikana mine to return to work or be fired, the miners insisted that they would "rather die" than return to "slavery".
Thirty-four striking miners were shot and killed at the mine, near Rustenburg, in North West, on Thursday when they stormed a police line.
"People have died already so we have nothing more to lose ... we are going to continue fighting for what we believe is a legitimate fight for living wages. We would rather die like our comrades than back down," said miner Kaizer Madiba.
President Jacob Zuma yesterday called for a week of mourning after the tragedy and set up an interministerial commission to deal with the crisis. He reiterated his call for a judicial inquiry.
Lonmin has refused to give in to the demands.
The JSE and London-listed company stood by the court order, obtained on August 10, that the miners return to work or be fired.
Madiba and his co-strikers watched 34 of their colleagues being shot and killed by police.
Armed with pistols, shotguns, pangas and traditional weapons, the miners stormed a line of police carrying semi-automatic rifles and pistols.
Yesterday, the miners vowed to fight to the death.
"The only thing that will end this strike is a positive response from management. I am still asking myself why management refuses to negotiate with us.
"We only want R12000 for rock-drill operators and a minimum wage of R7500 for everyone working underground," he said.
Madiba said the strikers would meet today to decide what to do next.
All they wanted, he said, was to be able to create a better future for their children back home.
Thursday's killings were against the backdrop of a week-long violent illegal strike by the Lonmin miners, in which 10 people were killed, including two policemen sent to bring calm to the situation, and two security guards, who were burned to death in their car.
Lonmin spokesman Barnard Mokwena yesterday defended the company's decision to re-issue the ultimatum, saying it applied only to rock-drill operators.
"There are many options on the table. It is not as if 'To fire or not to fire' is all we are considering."
Mokwena said it was not the company's decision to re-issue the ultimatum. Instead, he said, the wording was a consequence of the court order the company had obtained.
"The company is going through a mourning period and is focused on the needs of its employees and their families," he said.
But the ultimatum has angered the Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union (Amcu).
"It is too harsh of management to talk in this way," said Amcu treasurer Jimmy Gama, describing the ultimatum as "very unfair".
Frans Baleni, the secretary-general of the National Union of Mineworkers, said the situation was still very "sensitive" and it could not be expected that workers would take up their duties if they were threatened by more violence.
Zuma said yesterday: "We must avoid finger-pointing and recrimination. We must unite against violence from whatever quarter."
The inter-ministerial committee, which will be led by Minister in The Presidency Collins Chabane, is made up of North West Premier Thandi Modise and ministers including Mineral Resources' Susan Shabangu and Police's Nathi Mthethwa. They are due to visit Marikana today.
Zuma's spokesman, Mac Maharaj, yesterday said details of the judicial inquiry into the deaths of the miners would be made public this week.
The "Marikana massacre" has highlighted the problems affecting South Africa's mining industry.
Baleni pointed to "other hot spots in the platinum sector", hinting that there was a risk of a spillover of violence into other sectors.
Gideon du Plessis, general secretary of trade union Solidarity, said he knew of "early signs of the same conflict" in other places.
Chief executives - drawn from various mining sectors - met top government and trade union officials, as well as the Chamber of Mines, on Saturday to discuss the problems besetting the mining industry.
The meeting reportedly ended with the following goals defined:
Repair damage to the image of the mining industry;
Avoid a spillover of violence into other industries in the mining sector; and
Stabilise the industry to limit opportunities for what the meeting's participants described as "militant opportunists".
It is believed the last goal was in reference to expelled ANC Youth League president Julius Malema, who visited Marikana on Saturday.
He called for Zuma and Mthethwa's resignations because of the massacre.
The miners took a break from protests yesterday, sitting around in groups drinking, shaving and sharing memories of their dead comrades.
Though on Thursday hundreds of heavily armed police were patrolling Wonderkop, where the shooting took place, the only sign of a police presence yesterday was a roadblock set up for the police to search vehicles for weapons.
Police spokesman Captain Dennis Adriao said that though the situation was quiet but tense, a strong police presence in the area will be maintained until everything was under control.
The 259 strikers arrested in connection with the violent protests will appear in the Rustenburg Magistrate's Court today.


SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.Timbuck10
Posted 274 days ago"WE DEMUND"!!!!!
Enough already...
BornintheRSA
Posted 274 days agoGerriMichalska
you find unacceptable?
Is it acceptable that miners earn a minimum wage when they risk life and limb on a
daily basis? Who could find that acceptable?
Would they be living in shacks and shanty towns with no running water if they were
earning decent and fair wages??
Lonmin is unjust and it is time for Lonmin and the South African government to stop
ensconcing/enriching themselves on the backs of the workers on the bottom.
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 274 days agoMy understanding is that rock drillers start at an entry level of around R7,000 - excluding housing, performance bonuses, pension, medical and various other bonuses. That amount doubles for experienced drillers.
It would also be interesting if someone could find out if the unions are aware of just how financially fragile Lonmin is at the moment.
Abdulla-Saleeh
RSA.MommaCyndi
Even if it is net, deductions of R3,000 would be abnormally high on that salary. Unless there were court ordered deductions going off as well.
mbongwamugabe
Posted 274 days agoBornintheRSA
mbongwamugabe
Really ? it's fine if that is what you think happened there.
Polony_Lips
If you want to strike.... do so without the "monkeynastics"
The cops did the right thing... You are quick to comment a boy the cops and their actions from the recliner of you living room or the safety of your work office. You go and stand in front of a crown of "striking" wokaz and let them come at you with shot guns , pangs and knives.
Its the rules if engagement sweetie.... If you don't react when u have the opportunity to do so and you are in danger.... YOU WILL BE KILLED. Bottome line... If they didn't shoot they would have been killed.
I would have like to see pork chop JUJU infront leading them them. Then perhaps we would have been better off. But sadly he instigates from the side and then stands back. Sadly the poor miners know no difference and don't see that they are just the pawns
mbongwamugabe
Your hatred towards the future president[mr Malema] is amazing. Your wish about him mean nothing as you are nothing but less God, only God has the power to decide about Malema's future not some mickey mouse alein.
ForeignObserver
To directly address your original statement about being in a police state. Do you even live in South Africa? The police are a barely functioning organization - hardly able to tackle minor crime - let alone warrant the labelling of South Africa as a police state. Ridiculous hyperbole will get you no where.
You may also be amused that I disagree strongly with the tone struck by Polony_Lips on here as I find his comments are clearly written to agitate racial sensitivities. As such Polony_Lips should be ignored as much as possible. Even if he does make one or two good points there is no reason for dropping racial aspersions such as 'monkeynastics'.
With the notable exception of the Original Momma this website's commentators are largely internet trolls as far as can be ascertained.
MicaParis
Posted 274 days agoAs black and white South Africans we need to have tough conversations about how to heal the socially engineered wounds that resulted from that reality. These wounds continue to undermine our ability to reach for our dream as a nation. Accusations of being a pessimist, prophet of doom, traitor to the cause and worse are all cries of anguish by a wounded people who have a low tolerance for any hint of lack of sympathy or disloyalty.
To the many white South Africans who are impatient with the constant blaming of apartheid for our failures to govern and become a prosperous nation, I would like to plead for patience and self-reflection. We should not be mistaken to imagine that your higher social economic status is a product of superior effort if not ability. We should not succumb to amnesia of the corruption and incompetence of past colonial and apartheid governments. Neither should you be in denial about your responsibility for putting right what went wrong then. Our status as a citizen accords us rights but also demands responsibility from us to promote real unity.
One need only look at the disdain that many captains of industry have for the very people in political authority positions whom they corrupt. It is very sad to realize that Unions and top Government leaders are selling the soul and flash of our workers in exchange of fat BEE deals.
I remain convinced that ours is a country destined for greatness if only we are willing to commit to living our dreams of unity in diversity and respect for dignity every day at the personal, professional and political level.
This requires a commitment to conversations that may at times be uncomfortable, but in the web of the extended family setting there should be enough safety to allow for all to be heard. And if there isn’t, we need to start re-weaving these spaces to become safe.
QPCLCD308
```````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Very true, Mica, There is only one thing that ANC Politicians will always choose fat BEE deals even above the massacre of the poor workers and police! They have got nothing to loose, they are only gesturing as leaders, the leadership that might slip out of their hands at any time1 So why care a damn about the situation, better enrich your self with money before is too late! ANC Comrades know that politics are a temporary high risk game that in which must collect fortunes before it get too dark and late to collect, that is all!!
m1si2zi3nzo4
Posted 274 days agoi_stub_born
Posted 274 days agoBaleni, from NUM has a monthly salary of over 100000 (M&G), the rest of "leathers" are probably well paid as well. AMCU is not taken into account in the meetings between the concerned parties, obviously because ANC-COSATU must protect each other's backsides, and so the problems will go on and on..........
m1si2zi3nzo4
mbongwamugabe
i_stub_born
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 274 days ago..... some days our political masters are just too embarrassing for words. 34 men lay dead and over 100 are injured. Anyone involved who isn't sorry about how it turned out needs their heads read.
Abdulla-Saleeh
RSA.MommaCyndi
That takes callous to whole new lows !
Gormogon1
I see where your heart is. However, the media have only showed the weeping families of the miners killed by police. Why are they not showing the weeping families of the two police and security guards who were killed for simply doing their job? For that matter, the media felt nothing, nor showed any footage of the weeping families of the10 miners killed by other miners before this event took place.
I simply deplore this selective media coverage, and how they make out that the police were at fault by playing the sympathy card for a bunch of savage killers.
RSA.MommaCyndi
The media has always been guilty of going for the sensational aspect. Can't blame them, that is what sells and they are only supplying what we (the readers) demand.
My problem is the message this is sending. You can take a life and not feel regret? Even people who are defending themselves feel regret. If you don't, then you have lost all humanity. I shudder to think what the cops on the front line are going through. They must be completely traumatised by what happened. Now we have a woman (who has no idea what she is talking about) telling them they shouldn't feel 'sorry'. Yea, I don't see how that is going to encourage them to seek assistance from the police councillor.
QPCLCD308
MicaParis
I guess the police top dog is living by her ''surname'', absolutely nothing but feces, she is very weak to manage the Police Department, cannot even make a meaningful and honorable speech as a leader, shame ANC, we are in trouble! Nathi Mthetwa and Zuma has just given us another deadwood amid others who are already keeping the riffle rumbling, firing blanks as usual!!
Zuma had been advised wrong by his cronies (frienemies) once again!! We are just waiting for another court action to declare ''Phiyega/diarrhea'' unqualified and not fit for the position! Another perpetual failure and off side blunder from our Comrade President!!
Wiseguy
Posted 274 days agoThe NUM, and its alliance partners MUST recuse themselves from ANY role in these negotiations both in and outside of the boardroom !
While AMCU may well be a more "militant" union and a new start up clearly in competition with NUM, as long as it brings its members peacefully to the negotiations and adhere's to the labour laws of the country....it should be allowed to pursue its industrial action until a win-win solution is reached. If its members choose to act outside of the laws of this country....then they must unfortunately accept the consequances.
So if AMCU cannot function peacefully within the very liberal labour laws of this country......then its licence should be removed/cancelled and it should be outlawed/banned.
That said, Union bosses, the world over, use their members for self-enrichment and self-empowerment......invariably at the workers expense.....without exception!
Wiseguy
AMCU you need to reign your members in, make sure they and you as a union function within the laws of this country......
m1si2zi3nzo4
Posted 274 days agoRSA.MommaCyndi
Word for the day?
To attempt to prevent the every year strikes, the mining industry and the unions agreed to a two year deal. The workers and the unions couldn't give a tinkers about the volatility of the market. Their only focus is the wages.
Somehow, the rock drillers were not part of the package that NUM negotiated. The rock drillers got angry (think Implats) and started shouting. They then went directly to management to negotiate a package for themselves. Management and the rock drillers came to an agreement. NUM went ballistic about the management dealing directly with the rock drillers and threatened a walk out. The management then told the rock drillers that it had to go through NUM. The rock drillers were not impressed and AMCU got a large number of new recruits. NUM lost their required +50% representation and the ish hit the fan.
Now that isn't 'propaganda' that is (to the best of my knowledge) what happened.
m1si2zi3nzo4
RSA.MommaCyndi
Rudi7
Posted 274 days agoMangqeshane
Posted 274 days agomuk1
Posted 274 days agoPolony_Lips
Posted 274 days agoIn no way was this a massacre... If it was 18 woman and children that got slain in a rural village it would be a MASSACRE . The fact that they had pangs, spears, Shotguns and sidearms is no MASSACRE. Is this an media trait or a ANC trait ?
Just like Bhisho in the 90's .... Its not a MASSACRE when the protestors carry weapons
m1si2zi3nzo4
Brisvegas
Posted 274 days agoI reckon the ANC would have a hard time explaining this one...
Maybe a good time to rethink nationalising an industry on the decline
Polony_Lips
Polony_Lips
Posted 274 days agoBut you're missing the point, what happened in 1976 or 1960 is history, as this will be soon, there it was unarmed youth.... YES that was a massacre, but this cannot be compared to either Sharpville or any other incident.
Point made and you argue against it, so you seem to attack my statement. The mine workers were armed... .POINT... That means its not a massacre... GET IT
m1si2zi3nzo4
Polony_Lips
Polony_Lips
Amazing 18 miners are killed and there is an inquiry...
4000 farmers are killed in less than 24 months and its all cool ..... Weird isn't it
Fair&Just
There wasn't merely a thought of SAPS might being attacked, they were attacked even after first (calling on striking protestors to lay down arms + do not cross barrier) instructions and second (rubber bullets and stun grandes) stages were used!
The defensive SAPS manoeuvre wasn't a killing spree or massacre but a last resort by did you know a vastly outnumbered SAPS contingent
There is a difference between striking miners illegally protesting and striking miners illegally protesting armed with pangas, spears, side arms and shot guns.
Whom have killed those before the defensive SAPS manoeuvre had to be used are most probably the same whom instigated the malicious act on the SAPS whom merely were present because of the dangerous weapons carried by the illegally protesting striking miners.
Wont be surprized if when those Protesting Leaders whom have been causing not comply with standing Court Order, Killing Fellow Miners, Killing Security guards, Compiling Hit list for those to be killed & Killing SAPS officers be sentenced that cries of punishment too harsh, will be heard!
Ironically sentences of 6 years for rape or 10 years
when a farmer is brutally murdered are given but 20 years for stealing money is given!
donorfatigued
You can not call it anything less, when 3000 lethally armed men congregate on a hillside in an illegal gathering, refuse to disperse and then threaten police, meanwhile killing rivals, butchering two policemen and burning to death 2 security guards.
All the while, for many days, their witch-doctors are getting them psyched up for war amidst cries and chants of a very warlike nature, and issuing muti to make the bullets bounce off!
Crazy but true - you cannot make this stuff up!
The were determined to fight - they got their fight. Having exhausted a graduated force-response, the cops had no other means left to them, other than to run away - this was not going to happen!