Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41836.02
    UP 0.05%
    Top 40 : 3460.70
    UP 0.50%
    Financial 15 : 11971.78
    DOWN -0.24%
    Industrial 25 : 47413.26
    DOWN -0.51%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5832
    UP 0.38%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.4123
    DOWN -0.38%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3103
    DOWN -0.15%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0931
    DOWN -0.09%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2766
    DOWN -0.94%

  • Gold : 1357.7550
    DOWN -1.18%
    Platinum : 1461.5000
    UP 0.31%
    Silver : 22.2500
    DOWN -0.89%
    Palladium : 746.5000
    UP 0.88%
    Brent Crude Oil : 102.530
    DOWN -1.33%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Wed May 22 20:43:13 SAST 2013

NPA buckles under Marikana pressure

SIPHO MASOMBUKA | 03 September, 2012 00:07
One of the arrested miners waits in the back of a police van to be called into the Ga-RanKuwa Magistrate's court where he appeared with scores of others in connection with charges of public violence.

The National Prosecuting Authority buckled under pressure yesterday, provisionally withdrawing controversial murder charges against 270 Lonmin mineworkers.

Amid intensifying criticism, including from ANC treasurer-general Mathews Phosa, and threats of an urgent high court application for an order compelling President Jacob Zuma to release the miners by lunch time yesterday, NPA acting head Nomgcobo Jiba announced that the workers would be released this week.

The miners have been behind bars for more than two weeks after 34 of their colleagues were killed in a hail of police bullets.

They were initially charged with public violence. Murder charges under the common purpose doctrine were added later.

Jiba, without going into detail, revealed that she had overruled a decision by North West director of public prosecutions Johan Smit to collectively charge the miners with the murder of their colleagues.

Her decision, she said, was based on various concerns raised through prosecuting channels and the threat by the miners' lawyers to go to court today.

The decision was, ironically made on the day Phosa warned that charging the miners with murder could lead to another Marikana massacre.

On Friday, Justice Minister Jeff Radebe demanded answers "explaining the rationale behind such a decision".

Expelled ANC Youth League leader Julius Malema, who has been vocal in supporting the miners, and who decried "police brutality", on Thursday described the murder charges as "madness", saying that the policemen who fired on the miners should be charged instead.

Friends of the ANC Youth League, which is associated with Malema, blamed the Lonmin tragedy on the ANC leadership.

Floyd Shivambu, who is linked to the group, said: "If there were leadership in South Africa the lengthy, unreasoned, horrible and inhumane imprisonment of the mineworkers who survived the massacre would have been avoided."

The group has vowed to stand behind the workers, who continue to demand higher wages.

But, as acting head of the NPA Jiba said, she has the power to review decisions taken by her provincial directors.

On Friday, Radebe said: "There is no doubt that the NPA's decision has induced a sense of shock, panic and confusion within the members of the community and the general South African public."

Jiba revealed that she, after receiving several expressions of concern, sent a team to observe court proceedings and study a report by North West director of public prosecutions Smit.

"I also received a copy of representations addressed to the president by the attorneys representing the accused ... on Friday," Jiba said.

It was during a meeting with NPA leaders on Saturday that she decided to provisionally withdraw the murder charges.

Hours before Jiba's announcement, Lesego Mmusi, the miners' advocate, said the drafting of the application for a court order compelling Zuma to release the miners was almost complete and would be filed either last night or this morning.

After Jiba's announcement, Mmusi said: "We have not heard anything [official] from the NPA and we cannot decide [on] the court papers on the basis of media statements. We have to work according to what we have.

"We received a letter from the presidency [saying that Zuma would not accede to demands for the release of the miners] and we expect the same from the NPA. We can only comment once there is something official."

The decision was widely welcomed, with the ANC saying it would allow the commission of inquiry appointed by Zuma to investigate the massacre and the police to continue with their investigations.

"It is our expectation that at the end of the investigation the outcome will be implemented fully without fear or favour," ANC spokesman Jackson Mthembu said.

The central committee of the National Union of Mineworkers has called for the suspension of the policemen "that executed the Marikana massacre".

It called on the judicial commission of inquiry to find out, and make public, who gave the order to shoot at the workers with live ammunition .

The union's general secretary, Irvin Jim, said the police's action confirmed that post-1994 South Africa had not been transformed and the methods of the apartheid state and its violent machinery banished.

Jiba said the miners would be released in batches, starting today with those whose address could be verified. The rest will remain in custody until their next court appearance, on Thursday.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
Bungling bunch of incompetents. The ANC has lost their credibility a long time ago. Leaderless and corrupt to the bone.

EddieR

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
I suppose that coming to a "meeting" armed with sticks, spears, sharpened iron rods and a shotgun was just because they wanted to shoot a buck, and then cut it up with the spears, put those pieces on the iron rods, and make a fire with the sticks, so that they could have a braai?

MicaParis

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
Voila! Another faux pas by the NPA. That is cadre deployment for you!!

If my father is a Minister and he instruct another Minister in another Department to recruit his child because she has LLB qualification to be a State Law Adviser, thereby erupting up by the order of nepotism to the high profile risky post of being head of the NPA!! Is the Ministers daughter a best candidate for the JOB even though she posses legal qualifications!?

Jacob Zuma's tenure as the President has been characterized by extremely too much obvious legal blunders a person can think of , for a President who have a flat of legal advisers across all the government spectrum not to mention those who are scattered all over the Presidency's offices right under his nose, that must be a miracle serious!. Unfortunately all of them cannot even lift a finger! What is wrong!

A forensic investigations must be carried out to find out if the likes of Menzi Simelane, Jiba, Michael Hulley and Mokotedi Mpshe really have got ''legal qualifications'', really, a person who have got just a simple LLB, without any Post Graduate qualification fresh from University cannot make ''silly'' mistake such as the shenanigans that this ''cadres'' are currently displaying.

Qualifications can easily be bought at the Universities all over the world, ''money talks''! Does our ''legal gurus'' QUALIFY!? Well their ACTIONS to me suggest that this people must be having no ''legal'' formal qualifications that they really worked and passed for! Simple as that!

MushNdlane

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
Nomgcobo Jiba's late reaction to murder charges prefered on the miners is an indication of absence of leadership. There is serious lack of leadership in South Africa in general and in the long run our children will bear the brunt of it. Whenever there is a vacuum, demagogues like Malema will make political capital out of it.

Coming to Jiba, how come did she not send observers long before the trial started. Why did she only act after concerns were raised regarding the rationale to charge the miners of murder.

This country is crying for leadership. I think upright and metitorious leadership will not come from the current crop of political leaders across the board. The latter point was aptly stated by Mamphele Ramphele when she said that South Africans must stop remainign idle while waiting for a messiah to emerge, who is going to lead us. The onus is on us to become the architects of our own future. Where to from here? A civil society formation in the mould of the UDF is required at this stage of our history. This means that when we vote, let's not return a crop of leadership that is plundering the public purse. When they come for reelection let's answer them by saying we don't need them.

i_stub_born

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
Other than his LLB(Clicks) (Zuma Cum Fraude mention) advisors, as many as he might have, Zuma cannot afford the most important one: COMMONIS SENSUS.......

Zuma and the ANC Mafia Syndicate are beyond repair ........fortunately or infortunately, depending on the side of the fence..........

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
South African taxpayers could do better by sharing their deep pockets with the those who lost their loved ones, who incidentally constitute the sole bread winners in their villages. Its the taxpayer who foot the bill for the regime's style of ruling by 'commissions of inquiries'. Whilst this avoidance of accountability may have been acceptable in Angie, and Cele's maladministration, it is way too magnanimous in micro-management of Lonmin. Just how much did it cost the taxpayer for all those men in 'empty suits' to descent and micro-manage Lonmin? Will those ministers recoup the taxpayers' money from Ramaphosa and his mine magnates? Does it mean that the orphans will wait for the elite to win Mangaung before they can sue for their deceased? How are they expected to survive in the meantime? Mangaung is costing every citizen, now. Every accountability is shifted to commissions of inquiries, one after another. And lives of children and lost ones, must wait until the chief induna wins or loses. And then what? Cele has shown that even after reports, the elite can still use taxpayers' money to 'appeal' these outcomes. What are the implications for justice to those who lost loved ones, and the children who lost a semester in education?

Avatar

QPCLCD308

Posted 261 days ago
m1si2zi3nzo4 nice comment, and yet the poor miners will vote for cyril and co at the coming elections, i hope peolpe open thier eyes and vote wisely. ANC is damaged beyond repair.

QPCLCD308

Posted 261 days ago
Avatar
democratically the marikana miners have got a right to choose whatever they wish but i will be watching to see which political party they will vote for in 2014. Will theyn repeat the same mistake, let us wait and see.
Avatar

danny.archer3

Posted 261 days ago
Are you seriously asking that question??