Please enter your login details

You can also sign in with your Sowetan LIVE
and Sport LIVE account details.
   Sign Up   Forgot password?

Sign in with:

 
  • All Share : 41836.02
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Top 40 : 3460.70
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Financial 15 : 11971.78
    UNCHANGED0.00%
    Industrial 25 : 47413.26
    UNCHANGED0.00%

  • ZAR/USD : 9.5798
    UP 0.13%
    ZAR/GBP : 14.3981
    UP 0.12%
    ZAR/EUR : 12.3047
    UP 0.15%
    ZAR/JPY : 0.0929
    UP 0.16%
    ZAR/AUD : 9.2302
    DOWN -0.28%

  • Gold : 1365.6050
    DOWN -0.19%
    Platinum : 1460.5000
    DOWN -0.31%
    Silver : 22.1127
    DOWN -0.72%
    Palladium : 740.5000
    DOWN -0.07%
    Brent Crude Oil : 101.900
    DOWN -0.68%

  • All data is delayed by 15 min. Data supplied by I-Net Bridge
    Hover cursor over this ticker to pause.

Thu May 23 04:59:25 SAST 2013

Only ourselves to blame

ADRIENNE CARLISLE | 25 September, 2012 00:25
Rev Barney Pityana,

South Africans must take responsibility for their country's failures because they insisted on electing leaders without vision, basic competence or an understanding of democracy.

Human rights activist the Rev Barney Pityana, speaking in Grahamstown at Kingswood College's annual memorial lecture to celebrate the life of anti-apartheid activist Neil Aggett, said many of South Africa's failings could not be blamed on its evil apartheid past.

"We must blame nobody but ourselves for the tragedy of our education system, a collapsing health care system, a bloated but inefficient civil service, pervasive crime, and corruption that has become endemic.

"That is because we have not only elected a government without any intelligence collectively to understand what must be done, [it cannot] draw on the resources of the entire society to fix what is wrong.

"We have a government trapped in ideological blinkers that believes and behaves like it is unaccountable."

Pityana said if South Africans continued to endorse this failed leadership the result would be "continued chaos, extending inequality, burgeoning unemployment, poverty and the social evils that have become characteristic of much of our society."

He said the ANC and its allies treated with suspicion and hostility any ideas that did not reinforce their own "stereotypical reality" and sought to silence [conflicting ideas].

"The truths they seek to present must be suppressed. But we do indeed have a president, head of state and leader of the ruling party who was charged with rape, was investigated for serious crimes of corruption and who proudly purveys as his trademark his propensity to surround himself with a multiplicity of wives."

He said no country that had an unemployment rate of more than 40% should have such a smug government.

"The government is in no hurry to deal with these matters. Instead it is reported that public resources are being manipulated to enrich the few and to build a monument to Jacob Zuma's presidency by establishing a new town on Zuma's doorstep in Nkandla.

"And through it all this nation is fast asleep."

Pityana asked what it was that made people such as Aggett, Steve Biko, Rick Turner and Nelson Mandela visionaries.

"They knew that to be human meant they had to live in the freedom they believed in and never compromise their own humanity by succumbing to fear and embracing the irrationality that engulfed society."

He said it was the likes of Aggett who gave South Africa its constitution.

"The entire structure of government should be about galvanising resources to achieve the constitutional objectives of human dignity, equality, and the advancement of human rights and freedoms.

"Only when we are progressing towards the realisation of that ideal will the deaths of the likes of Neil Aggett not be in vain," said Pityana.

Aggett, who was a pupil of Kingswood College, died in detention in 1982 aged 28.

Pityana, a former vice-chancellor of Unisa and a former chairman of the Human Rights Commission, is now rector of the College of the Transfiguration in Grahamstown.

SHARE YOUR OPINION

If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.

SecretVoice

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Now why are there not more people acknowledging the governments complete failure.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
karlmarx

''''''Our government is not a complete failure, you moron! Why are your comments always sarcasric and condenscending towards blacks?''''''

They are almost there !...... Just hang on for a short while longer !
Avatar

SecretVoice

Posted 239 days ago
KarlMarx1
I never said anything about people of colour. You are the one who mentioned it. I said the government failed on most of its duties. Just to help you with the thinking process I will list it for you.
Education = total collapse ( see elsewhere in today's TL)
Defense = total collapse ( see elsewhere in today's TL)
Policing = total collapse. They need the defunct Army to help them combat crime.
Health = total collapse .
Local government = total collapse
Etc etc.
I say again this government is a total failure. Thank you for admitting that it is because it only employ people of colour. In fact this is what the reverend also say. So I guess you and the reverend got it right this time.

rahima

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Definition of STUPID: Knowing the truth, seeing the truth, but still believing the LIES.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
A perfect example, told by the master story teller himself, that he will create 500 000 jobs per year, but it never materialized !

l984

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
100% spot on.

The so-called 'leaders' are merely the projection and reflection of the majority that has elected them.

Nothing more, nothing less.

POST94

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
We hear you Pityana and just wondering when you'll get over your 'sour grapes'.

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
''''''Pityana said if South Africans continued to endorse this failed leadership the result would be continued chaos''''''

Everything said in a few words !

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Prof Pityana,
You should be blaming the opposition parties too. The concept of democracy cannot be instilled without educating the public to the alternatives. Come election time, the voters will be threatened with the 'return of apartheid' and their grants being taken away - then they will be given the carrots of promised houses, jobs etc. How do you think they will vote if they don't know that both the threats and the carrots have less substance than the steam off their tea?
Avatar

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 239 days ago
IHateThem
"This country will not be handed over back to whites."

Thank you for proving my point :)
Avatar

l984

Posted 239 days ago
"This country will not be handed over back to whites."

This was most certainly NOT the point the Prof was trying to make.

"He said the ANC and its allies treated with suspicion and hostility any ideas that did not reinforce their own "stereotypical reality" and sought to silence [conflicting ideas]."

Point proven.

Mike123

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Don't blame me! I didn't vote for the morons!
Avatar

BAMBINA

Posted 239 days ago
well said neither did I and the ones that are first to moan about service devilliveries etc are the ones that voted in these corupt useless morons. But like sheep they will follow and vote the thieving morons once again.
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
Bambina

Please do not insult the intelligence of sheep.

i_stub_born

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
""""You really underestimate RSA voters. We do not vote a certain way because of threats.""""

.........nope......the majority voted and will vote out of sheer stupidity and ignorance. They choose their vote with their sentimentalism before the rationalism...........They know by voting for a corrupt party, the same corrupt elite will be in power again and again......and they still do it !!!!!!!
Avatar

SuiGeneris

Posted 239 days ago
Hear Hear !

Tazzman

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
To some extend I agree with the Reverend, but before we blame the voters we must critically analyze the “Evolution of an ANC voter”, in 18years a typical ANC voter has evolved from a Revolutionary voter, to a companionate voter and now there is a new voter in town an illiterate, uneducated social welfare reliant voter with corrupt state officials and tenderpreneurs leading these illiterate pack. Majority of the voters do no see anything wrong with the status quo, all they are interested in is social grants and state tenders.
Avatar

Robrt4Mugabe99

Posted 239 days ago
I would like to differ with your perception, very bleak and incoherent , to assist you when we talk of anc we are talking of well established brand with strong structures compared to any opposition party in the country.

Iam referring here of workers, civil org and student bodies like COSAS/SASCO/PYF who are making huge contribution when comes to elections, for you to come up and mumble about illiteracy you are a joke
Avatar

rahima

Posted 239 days ago
@Robert4Mugabe99

You forgot to mention SADTU - the destroyer of any bright future for many millions.

If the ANCpf is so organized, how did they allow over 40 schools to be closed for 4 months over a road dispute? Dream on.
Avatar

rahima

Posted 239 days ago
@Robert4Mugabe

YOU exactly fit the definition of STUPID: Knowing the truth, seeing the truth, but still believing the LIES.

manga2

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Using the GIGO Principle, we can conclude that it is the Prof and co's graduates that are failing our government institutions. Their output (graduates) cannot even put together an implementation plan for one KPA with 1-3 Key activities.

You only have to look at the concoction of subjects the Univerties put together for most of their courses. It's pathetic.

Sometimes you get a graduate engineer who cannot tell a cement mix from a concrete mix. Then these same engineers must be unleached to the government institutions to go and supervise experienced contractors. More often they get to supervise the Malema types of contractors. You then have a case of a blind man leading another blindman.

Can you really blame the government for employing so called graduates from the institutions led by the likes of Barney Pityana? This lousy Prof needs to understand that polititians set policies and strategic direction (MTSF) and then the technocrats unpack and set the implementation ball rolling.

i_stub_born

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
""""""We must blame nobody but ourselves for the tragedy of our education system, a collapsing health care system, a bloated but inefficient civil service, pervasive crime, and corruption that has become endemic.

"That is because we have not only elected a government without any intelligence collectively to understand what must be done, [it cannot] draw on the resources of the entire society to fix what is wrong.""""""""

.....That certainly does not ring as "tribal ideology"..........

Irrespective his allegiances to the delusional failure of Mbeki, to pinpoint an example of mismanagement and misuse of public funds as Zumaville while hundredths of other rural areas lack of the most basic necessities and services as a monument to a semi-literate man appointed as leader is not "tribalism" either........

Many dubious tenders and contractors of all colors have and will benefit of these grandiose plans as we have seen.....but it is not for the benefit of the society or the country in general, but for the comfort and ostentation of the mafia elite in attendance..........

RSA.MommaCyndi

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Barney Pityana was in charge of UNISA. UNISA is an internationally credited university. You also don't get a degree in engineering and then immediately become chief engineer. To the best of my knowledge, it takes about 10 years of work experience before an engineering graduate gets to call anything close to the shots.

How Pityana is to blame for illiteracy in junior school is just beyond anything vaguely related to logic and the only reason to haul out the 'tribalism' card is because the 'racist' card would be too laughable. It really is sad how any black person who questions the populist ideas is a 'coconut', 'puppet', 'tribalist' or 'Uncle Tom'.

manga2

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
We hear of good non governmental organisations that are becoming part of the solution through a number of constructive interventions including the last resort of taking government to court. That's laudable compared to the know-it-all and condescending attitude displayed by this Professor. How can a Professor make a sweeping statement saying there's not a single intelligent Minister in our cabinet? The country would be in trouble!! Yes there are failures. But only a stupid person with an axe to gring can wilfully ignore the number of successes of our government.

Fairness should apply to both your favourites and the despised.

Txmafia1

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Looking for answers in the past is great but are our current problems the same as those that Biko, Aggett and Rick Turner had to overcome to bring democracy to this country. These great people did not mind giving up their life for the many these were people that gave a face to South Africa a human face , they were patriots sons of the soil. All I see in all these comments are people not worried about south africa and their fellow rather people more intrested going up the ladder of greed . None of you here care about the poor accept as a stat to prove each other wrong .What we need is people who will stand up and fight for the poor and south africa a grave is being served to many in this country and all because everybody fears losing favor with factions or parties with more that one hand in the pie. Mr Pityana thanks for the analysis but what we need to know what are you going to do open the eyes of the blind , all my educated friends commenting here what are you doing to rescue your fellow south african ?
What the ruling party has done or not done we are mainly resposible for not bringing them to book. I quote "In a democratic situation, it is the majority that prevail. I can't change the rules because you want to make a particular point" Yet the majority of south africans are unemployed , misled and living on the edge of beggary. Yes the question remains is the majority being catered for , If not will we just talk about it or will we contest it ?
Avatar

kalibanache

Posted 239 days ago
TX mafia, Look friend when you ask what us educated are doing let me help you with one thing. The least anybody can do and the strength in any economy is the accumulation of working people paying taxes, The more people working the more the government can do. When you open handedly ask what are we doing about the poor, Why not ask your leaders. I am fortunately someone that has a trade and ability to make money from the skills I have, Even better for me is plenty thousands of skilled tradesmen have left our shores to seek a safer environment, so yet a bigger demand for me. My dad retired leaving 50 workers to a new buyer, All our hearts ache that the new owner has laid them all off, You dont understand the terrible cause and effect of having rotten leaders. You should praise and respect any educated man living in SA, we contribute to 30 % minimum of the entire countries budget. The very same budget that pays a woman R1000 for every child she pops? We are carrying this country to unrealistic proportions, Our government has officials that own oil refineries and we paying too much for petrol, Food is costing so much even us skilled cannot afford, the camels back is breaking fast. Dont ask what we are doing, Ask yourself how much longer before we are all stuffed, lets stand together and fight the rotten amongst us, black or white !:)
Avatar

Txmafia1

Posted 239 days ago
@kalibanache as you realize I said what will you do to assist(rescue) your fellow man, like most "educated people" you took the capitalist route there by ensuing your pocket rather than ensuing the most important factor being opening the eye of your fellow man in getting what he deserves and what he voted for and most importantly getting what he was promised. As far as the educated are concerned the only ones that challenge the Hypocrisy we see are the ones that do not have 5 - 10 fingers in more than one pie like you. The question we need to ask ourselves is this "Can we continue in this manner" were the educated feel cheated and the poor feel marginalized. First we need to get as many people as possible Educated so that education becomes a norm rather than treating it like a Dynasty , people that obstruct the education process should be charged with treason as that not only cripples the poor but the educated as well therefore crippling what you may call the economy.We have an opportunity here to rethink what our economical standards should be I mean we keep saying we are educated , yet we use the blue prints of other countries , why not find a solution that will cater for ZA . I quote "“Youth of Africa, globalisation such as it is, does not please you. Africa has paid too high a price dearly for the mirage of collectivism and “progressisme” to yield to that of laisser-faire.
“Youth of Africa, you believe that free-trade is beneficial but that it is not a religion. You believe that competition is a means but not an end in itself. You don’t believe in laisser-faire"
Sir "bo pudi bakgonwa ke ba ba dinaka"

Shongweni

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
The man is dead on the money.

kalibanache

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Cannot argue with this man, What he says in 100% true. He only echoes what all us educated already knows. As for the many who are brought up in SA, Common sense makes no sense. Even the thick leader we have could improve things or improve peoples mindsets by saying fruitful things. I have a theory, Apartheid we all agree was counter productive and plain stupid but can it only be blamed on the aggressors? Can i blame a bully for bullying me without taking some responsibility? Can a drunk blame bottle stores? Can any man fairly blame their parents for a terrible life they have? With any problem responsibility needs to be owned and accepted before a healing process can develop. I would have thought Africans that were once suppressed would celebrate their new reality, different from their fathers and their fathers living in a land where they are free, Free to work, free to learn, free to determine a better future. Granted expectation and envy can bugger this all up! People of SA still think that you have something because you are white, forgetting the nurtured upbringing we may have had, The importance placed on education and the opportunities allowed because of this. We have every mineral known to planet earth yet our mining sector contributes nearly 8% of countries earnings? We should grow it to 30%, how many more opportunities and work that would give. Our farmers are of the best in the world, we can triple our farming or make it 10x more and lower our cost of living and increase exports, Sound governance and multi racial leaders would welcome more investors. We had shortsightedness in the old SA but now we seem to be ruled by blindness. Lets stand together, we can turn things around

Tsafendason

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
The Prof is making a lot of valid points on this issue. but we also know the Prof hates Zuma for defeating Mbeki in Polokwane and was never shy to say that in public, and as such, it is difficult to judge with him whether he is being sincere of just another personal attack on Zuma.

All COPE members, whetever valid point they may make will always and rightly so be viewed with the suspicion it deserves, moreso because they always try and present the problems of teh country as those brought by the Polokwane Pirates, when in fact it was the ANC itself even during Mbeki's time that is teh cause of most of our failures as a country.

Zuma is but part of a problem, the entire party which the likes of Pityane and other Cope sympathisers want us to believe was holy, is thr problem!!

Ozgood

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Most thinking people saw what was coming and did not support the ANC. It is mainly in the rural areas thatthis bias towards the ANC is the strongest. The people are afraid to anger the ancestors etc..

olibo

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
It has become fashionable for black intellectuals to publicly criticise the ANC government and receive praises from the white establishments. I would have no problem with the likes of Pityana exercising their constitutional right to freedom of speech, but they are to blame for the mess in the ANC for failing to accept defeat in Polokwane and stay to renew the party. After Polokwane it became a downward spiral that God knows who will help us. It is for this reason I cannot see anyone capable of renewing the party amongst the current leaders and potential nominees. For the ANC to survive, it needs a leader with integrity and unfortunately all of the potential candidates have black marks. Zuma (arms-deal corruption and Zumaville), Motlante (Iraq oil benefits with his partner and being a lame duck), Sexwale (allegations of corruption and potential to sell the country for the biggest price), Ramaphosa (he forgot that he was once a union leader and behaves like a capitalist), Manuel (he will sell the country to IMF and Britain, just like Old Mutual, Anglo-America and ABSA (his wife benefited)).

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
Its ironic that Pityana is repeating what everyone said, or knew, before Polokwane. Even the vulgar political elite agreed that Zuma was incompetent, but their excuse was that he would 'unite' the alliance. They never mentioned that this 'unity' was no more than clubbing against Mbeki, in a demonstration of compassion for Zuma. Mbeki expedited the collapse of a house of cards, that Mandela painstakingly put together, using unknown and disregarded principles of human rights. This glue only stuck because of its nicer soundbites, as everyone felt vulnerable at the time. After the elite gained control of the state machinery, they have been chipping at almost every part of the constitution, and arrogantly declare it as an obstacle to 'transformation' - read totalitarianism. They have now arrogantly interpreted the favourable clauses of the constitution to their benefit, and arrogantly side-stepped or ignored the more taxing ones.

It is the illiterate voter who is at the receiving end, but will continue returning the same incompetence to power, because he has been conditioned to see nothing else. After living all his life without a vote, voting dictatorship into power is far much better, because as unemployed, he has no tax money to lose, through corruption. The only loser would be big business and the employed, but both are allied to the ruling elite, through BEE's and COSATU. So, illiteracy and unemployment, pay the elite handsomely.

BootC

Posted 239 days ago
Avatar
@ uShwi-nent'encane
I do not accept Prof Pityana's view as 100% accurate. But to continue dividing the country by some (including Robert4Mugabe) will not assisting the problems faced by the country.
As much as I do not like seeing our beloved nation falling back to pre-1994 era, statements like these can create impressions of one nation superior than the other. Let's stop this nonsense of polarising our people on racial/tribal lines and confront the evils that threaten to destroy our democracy!
Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
The dumb thing about ethnicity - which includes racial categorisation - is that those who find anything common amongst themselves, always categorise the rest of society as "bad", "untrustworthy", etc. Only those who fall under their self-categorisation, are the best, and deserve everything nature can offer.

For that reason, all those who categorised themselves as "white", stopped complaining about incompetence, but the elite had to invent "Whiteness" in "Black" comments, in order to justify why they are the best, and must rule the rest. Even if racial categorisation were non-existent, the elite would still invent a strawman, to justify their right to rule, just like apartheid elite.
Avatar

Robrt4Mugabe99

Posted 239 days ago

It is strange that people like yourself comment about Zumaville yet people like myself being a stakeholder of that village is quiet, yet when we pose questions , you become numb , please live business to us as business people stop making foolish comments about Zumaville because all you know is to spew venom on keyboard. We are on the ground making sure the country is well functioning, if you do away with Zumaville do you know you are crashing thousand jobs, small business people around Inkandla who are online to supply that mall are going to crash , as well as more jobs to be created and secured .

Please black people after going to learning centres we need to look at the situation and become analytical ,creative and innovative. It is bloody stupid for a black man to make negative comments about Zumaville yet when whites are developing Centurion , they feel great , is it because a white is suppose to make good things not a black man or are we justifying Verwoeds mentality that a black man is incapable

Avatar

m1si2zi3nzo4

Posted 239 days ago
@Robrt4Mugabe99 or uShwi-nent'encane

Perhaps you will be able to tolerate other people's dismay at a president building his own town in Nkandlaville. You need to understand that half of the money he will use is paid by every taxpayer, including the oncoming eToll. We are not aware of any city that was built by a country's taxpayer, at a time when very people pay such tax. As a state official, or a BEE, remember that your riches also come from the taxpayer, and you do not produce anything in return. Furthermore, a town is a product of a productivity, either in the extraction of natural resources, and agricultural activity. It is not a town, for a town's sake, where we used to believe that it is where we could get money. It gets build out of investors' money, who have a stake at the exploitation of natural resources identified in a place. After all the natural resources have been extracted, most towns die, unless their economy is diversified. Otherwise, there is no point for businesses to come and establish themselves in an unproductive village, without any natural resources. Only the construction BEE's as front companies will benefit from Nkandlaville, but at the expense to the country as a whole, and to the destruction of rural life, which is the only life the izicholo neyiqhaza understand best. It spells death to life as they know it, for a few capitalist to exploit whatever remains and leave afterwards.
Avatar

i_stub_born

Posted 239 days ago
....ha ha ha ha.........so much for an "educated businessman" ...........but of course, 'tenderpreneurship' is a "business venture" one could say..............
Avatar

uShwi-nent'encane

Posted 239 days ago
@BootC
That’s precisely the point I was addressing with my comment earlier (which interestingly have been deleted). Prof Pityana uses tribal rant in supporting his false argument. His head is so high up in the clouds that he seems to genuinely believe that he can fool us all in masking his vindictive measures, setting one tribe against the next to discredit the man. To condense the current government’s efforts on rural development to the planned iNkandla development is ludicrous to say the least, a reasonable logic test dictate that we define it as such. I then pose the question, why this gentleman hasn’t been exposed for what he is, an angry, vindictive academic.
Avatar

uShwi-nent'encane

Posted 239 days ago
@M1si2zi3nzo4
This is truly courtesy on my part; I’d be lying to you if I say I fully understand the point you were making on your post. “We are not aware of any city that was built by a country's taxpayer…” I take it the use of a word “city” was a deliberate exaggeration; iNkandla can be a town at the most, to define it as a city would be a bit of a stretch. Please enlighten us then who in your opinion should pay for rural development in this country. I can however share with you in the meantime that currently there are no less than 5 projects in the Eastern Cape aimed at upscaling villages to town status through infrastructure development, all done with tax payers’ money, and there are many similar initiatives in other provinces.