'ANC loves only power'
Anti-apartheid activist Mamphela Ramphele has slammed the ANC for its backing of the Traditional Courts Bill, sky-high unemployment and the appalling standard of education.
Ramphele was speaking yesterday at the University of Cape Town's School of Business on the "Marikana Fallout".
As on previous occasions, she had harsh words for the ANC and the way in which it governs.
She spoke on a wide range of issues, including the mining and grape-farm strikes in Western Cape, and the role of labour unions.
Ramphele said the ANC treated voters "like children" and that the only time it would feel it had a duty to serve citizens would be when it feared it was in danger of losing power.
"Come election time, it will appeal to you to vote for the party of Mandela, [it will] appeal to you to vote for the only liberation movement [and] appeal to you not to vote for the DA because they will take you back to apartheid," said Ramphele.
"It's almost treating you like children and, unfortunately, we don't have civic education - where people understand that it is not possible to be taken back to apartheid.
"If you are poor and uneducated, you wonder if it is not possible that it can happen again."
Brothers Sipho and Barney Pityana, Rhodes University vice-chancellor Saleem Badat and businessman Reuel Khoza are among the many struggle activists who have spoken out against the ANC recently.
In September, Barney Pityana angered The Presidency during his Neil Aggett memorial lecture in Grahamstown.
He said: "We must blame nobody but ourselves for the tragedy of our education system, a collapsing healthcare system, a bloated but inefficient civil service, pervasive crime, and corruption that is endemic.
"We have a government trapped in ideological blinkers that believes and behaves like it is unaccountable."
His brother, Sipho, writing ahead of the convening of the commission of inquiry into the Marikana massacre, made similar observations.
He said that if one reflected on why 34 miners were shot and killed by the police, one could only blame "an acute failure of leadership in the ANC and the government it leads".
In April, Khoza, writing the chairman's foreword in Nedbank's annual report, questioned the quality of South Africa's ruling politicians - "political leadership's moral quotient is degenerating," he said.
Shortly after Khoza's comments, Badat referred to the "culture of disdainful conduct and service, sheer indifference to the needs of people, and a sore lack of ethical and accountable leadership".
Speaking at a graduation ceremony, Badat suggested that South Africans had been "numbed into silence" and that their "citizen's duty" was limited to voting every five years.
Yesterday, Ramphele lambasted the unions. She said that, unless they evolved, they were committing "suicide" and the strikes leading up to Marikana demonstrated workers' increasing lack of faith in many unions.
She said her heart bled when she looked at the calibre of educators.
"I come from a family of teachers. When I think about the apology that is called teachers in many of the schools my heart bleeds because we are condemning young, poor kids to being left in the hands of people who can't look after themselves.
"Many of those teachers who are members of the [SA Democratic Teachers' Union] are alcoholics, some are hooked on drugs and many are indebted to no end."
But Ramphele said some unions still had credibility, such as the National and Professional Teachers' Organisation of SA.
Ramphele slammed the Traditional Courts Bill, saying if enacted it would return the country to where apartheid "left us in 1994".
She said South Africa needed to reinvent itself after the Marikana tragedy but warned of " opportunists who are riding on the back of Marikana and agricultural labour problems".
She said the country needed to introduce national service to counter the skills shortage, turn mining and agriculture into highly skilled industries, and eliminate illiteracy if the economy were to improve.
SA Democratic Teachers' Union media officer Nomusa Cembi described Ramphela's comments as "derogatory".
"Teachers are a reflection of the community they come from. We feel grossly insulted. She acts as if she lives in a glass tower."



SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.Shongweni
Posted 188 days agobugsy
AfricaRevolt2011
Posted 188 days agoWiseguy
The truth hurts and they are trying their utmost to gag, obfuscicate and deny all criticism.......instead of dealing with the obvious problems, which would require self introspection, maturity and ultimately behavioural changes.......they carry on in denial! Trying their best to pass laws/acts and anything that will stiffle the truth.......it would be very hard for them to claim they are the political party of the people......there actions have indeed opened a large GAP on the political stage! Hopefully one of the opposition parties will fill soon as the current ANC seem relunctant to do the right thing for the people......and that means ALL the people!
The traditional courts bill is a complete joke and if it doesn't stand up to constitutional scrutiny(which I doubt) it should be dumped! If they ram it through, then I would urge all lawyers in RSA to challange each and every case they can get coming out of the traditional areas in our courts, and make sure one of the defendants is the "House of traditional leaders".....who should be held accountable esp. by means of civil claims!
POWER TO THE PEOPLE!!
VUKILE ABANTU VUUUUKKKKIIIIILLLLLEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!
Mike123
Posted 188 days agoLerroyMphela_Sr.
datraveller
eyetieinSA
Posted 188 days agoAaronGumede
Posted 188 days agoThuka-Thuka
Loggenberg
I think you forgot to make your point.
What you wrote above can be a response to any article about the ANC
Wiseguy
She was Steve Biko's close companion and that is the only truth in your comment !
AaronGumede
Not long ago JSC refused to appoint Gauntlet siting 'humility' as their reasons and there she comes running and remember Gauntlett is not the only capable person who was not appointed but she made noise in the media on account of Gauntlett. I can give you many more instances where I listened to her and found her annoying
The ANC share the blame on unemployment and my reasoning is around privatisation of state entities which I know many whites and DA support that, but private sector is a racist group which only cater for whites. Now how can a normal and responsible government privatise in such a situation. In some cases they gave their service companies to foreign companies who are not briniging new knowledge, skill or technology, and as far as I am concerned, they messed up. Already we had many low qualified people as a result of apartheid and apartheid regime was using parastatals to generate skills and employ low qualified whites, that was brilliant.Now how can ANC come with more than 10million illeterate and unskilled udults but sell all their bargaining power and then distribute grants? Mbeki and the then ANC leadership did it and many still praise Mbeki today even though he enlave the black more. In education, the ANC could have improved in areas where apartheid regime oppressed the most by channeling more resources but YES instead thy sh**t on every thing.
Bono
We need more people with her integrity and her ability to analyse the current political climate!!
AaronGumede
Are you sure that your name potray you correctly, nothing tribal on my comment, are sure that you know what you talk about? You arenot making sense, whatever you call it ,companion, chery, girlfriend, it boils down to a single point.
AaronGumede
Lets have such people who can be open minded and deal with all issues. Lets not sing praises while leading her to what we want and portray is a championship and brilliant.
Wiseguy
Your initial comment was "tribal/patriarchal" in nature as it attempted to stereotype women and this wonderful, bright, clever, caring and thoughtful woman in particular in a NEGATIVE way..........and you CANNOT stereotype someone(particularly a woman in RSA) who has the courage to stand up in a patriarchal society drowning in a sea of corruption/nepotism/maladministration and says IT IS WRONG......WE NEED TO FIX IT!!
Much like the Apartheid regime tried to stereotype, demonise and belittle the teachings and leadership of Nelson Mandela......and when they couldn't accomnplish that, they used their "secrecy bill" to lock him away from society......and that didn't work either!
GermanMouser
Wiseguy
RSA.MommaCyndi
I find your misogynistic views on women to be highly insulting.
BandileNodada
Go hang by the way, we not here to boost your ego or confidence.
Stirrer
Posted 188 days agoThis is great - the more the prominent (black) people speak truth to power, the sooner this fake ANC (with all their Walt Disney character leaders) will realise that they must up their game! Relying on the real ANC's liberation record is no longer enough to ensure that the fake ANC will stay in power.
Thuka-Thuka
GermanMouser
Posted 188 days agoBut I don’t think these criminals will allow you to come closer to them, " you need to have a criminal element in you then you will qualify to be among the gods”
SuiGeneris
Posted 188 days agoDon't just talk about the no confidence vote against Zuma - DO IT !
After that we can all pick up the pieces and exalt this this country to the heights that it is capable of.
skhokho21
Posted 188 days agoJomo_Bez
AaronGumede
Wiseguy
m1si2zi3nzo4
Anticrooks
skhokho21
Posted 188 days agoSuiGeneris
The ''solutions'' offered by the ANC are voted in by the majority vote to suit their style of governance of the country.
The ANC simply reject anything that they don't like by voting against it.
Alternative solutions by the opposition can only be implemented with a much stronger representation - something like an almost 50/50 distribution of power or if the opposition have the majority vote.
Matseleng
Sasha*-Fierce
Posted 188 days agoThe situation between Ramphele and the ANC is like that of the pot bottom calling the kettle bottom black! My reasoning in terms of the above is that, the pot is sooty (being placed on a fire), while the kettle is clean and shiny (being placed on coals only), and hence when the pot accuses the kettle of being black, it is the pot's own sooty reflection that it sees. That is to say that the pot accuses the kettle of a fault that only the pot has, rather than one that they share.
The truth is that Ramphele would have kept quite if she was part of the government, remember, there are no permanent enemies or friends in politics, look at Balindlela now! Politics will never be fair, perhaps God sidelined Ramphele so that she can be the voice of reason within the black cabal!
Matseleng
Tokolosh
Posted 188 days agoandmuchmore
Posted 188 days agodanny.archer3
Posted 188 days agoandmuchmore
GermanMouser
I guess these murderous have been listening for the past 18 yrs, that’s why things are so mess-up in this country
Stirrer
I think that, as a voting drawcard for black voters, she is more effective outside the DA at this stage - .
The gulf between leaving the ANC and joining the DA is still a two-step process for the majority of voters.
Wiseguy
Posted 188 days agoYou need to understand ,we as a country and specifically as an evolving society, need leaders who are non-partisan, of high moral standing, ethical, honest who hold our politicians and our political parties accountable for the poor performance ! And, btw, the reason that the ANC comes in for much more criticism than the DA...is the ANC currently holds a LOT more power than the DA.....capiche?? It has nothing to do with RACE....get over yourslves already??
We NEED more of her type....a LOT more.
Not more partisan politicians....!
danny.archer3
Wiseguy
I myself try and remain non-partisan as much as possible. While those in power, who abuse their positions of power make it difficult to remain non-partisan, doesn't mean there isn't or shouldn't be a place in our political landscape for objective analysis. Many people do not agree 100% with ANY of our current political parties or their ideologies or how they do business........so we need to recognise this and allow for non-partisanism.....their objective assesments of the political climate/situation should carry "extra weight"! One would hope?
skhokho21
Posted 188 days ago"high moral standing, ethical, honest"
For fukc sake, the woman was sleeping with a married man without protection, when JZ did it "you" say he has no values, morals & ethics. This woman is a howler and an opportunist, good that Dibas chose Graca. I dare her criticise or join DA.
Wiseguy
That is simply what she is doing......speaking truth to power!
Did I say I thought she should be president of RSA ? No
And yes, I do expect, the President of RSA to show respect to the "office" and prioritise it over his/her personal sex life! Don't you ?
buddi
It seems to worry you that many years ago she had a relationship with Steve Biko. By the way this was in the days before HIV.
Your president makes a habit of sleeping with women who are not his wife, and have children with them. He has four/five wives for heaven's sake, is that not enough for a man his age.
You cannot compare his morals to Ramphele's.
Robrt10Mugabe99
Posted 188 days agoI know this woman has been darling for white people in SA, however I have been in doom and gloom what she has done, is there anyone one who can give me a little bit of insight about this woman, altist 5 key issues tangible
Matseleng
2. She was an executive director at world bank. (Master)
3. She was a chairperson to Anglo American executive board. (Capitalist)
4. She once turned downs a position as a minister of Education. (Coward)
5. She has done nothing for the poor that she claims to represent.(Hypocrete)
Stirrer
Matseleng :
1. Lol, she was a mistress to Bra Steve... (the have a child together).
-----They actually had two, their baby daughter died and their son was born after Biko was murdered (Mother)
2. She was an executive director at world bank. (Master)
-----She is the first South African to hold this position (Pioneer)
3. She was a chairperson to Anglo American executive board. (Capitalist)
-----As well as Transnet, and Trustee of Nelson Mandela Childrens Fund, IDASA, Mo Ibrahim Foundation, and has numerous international degrees and awards (Versatile)
4. She once turned downs a position as a minister of Education. (Coward)
-----She probably felt an educational professional like Jonathan Jansen was better suited to this position (Intelligent)
5. She has done nothing for the poor that she claims to represent.(Hypocrete
-----Besides being a founder of the Black Conciousness Movement, where she organised community development programmes resulting in her banishment (Hero)
Robrt10Mugabe99
Posted 40 minutes ago
No she was nt the first SA to be appointed in the world bank , this is nt true, absolutely not true
Stirrer
My sources have her as being appointed one of four Managing Directors of World Bank (with important portfolios). Can't think of any other South African with such a high position in the organisation!
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 188 days agoGermanMouser
buddi
Posted 188 days agoMy point exactly and one that many anc voters don't understand. You don't have to vote for the DA, but vote so that the anc does not have such a huge majority. They are arrogant with power. They think they don't have to answer questions in parliament, insult other MPs in parliament, are corrupt, and use money fraudulently. They just do as they jolly well please, because they know that they will win each election with a huge majority, and at the moment there's very little anyone can do about it.
Why do you think there are so many court cases? Its the only way to make the anc do the right thing.
Mangqeshane
Posted 188 days agoAmazingly, including the media, it treats its readership/viewership/listenership as child force feedign it what it wants.
skhokho21
Posted 188 days agoBuddi for as long as you attack, the ANC & Gov, you will never have the majority, I don`t care who says what, DA is a party with interests of white people and ANC is a party with interests of black people, never mind the k*k by JZ, his time is up, he won`t complete this term, the man was a mistake we know that now.
RSA.MommaCyndi
I was dreadfully disappointed to hear that she had been given the opportunity to put her actions where her mouth is but I haven't heard her side of the story as to why she turned it down. Until I know both sides of the story, I'm willing to give her the benefit of the doubt.
Why does everyone have to be a political puppet in your world? I have no political affiliations but that doesn't mean that I don't vote or that my voice is irrelevant. To be honest, anyone who has a political affiliation, I don't listen to them as they are on an agenda and won't come close to being fair minded or honest
Matseleng
RSA.MommaCyndi
ppss
Posted 188 days agoandmuchmore
Posted 188 days agoskhokho21
Posted 188 days ago"Many of those teachers who are members of the [SA Democratic Teachers' Union] are alcoholics, some are hooked on drugs and many are indebted to no end."
This general statement is not fair on many teachers that are working hard.
"But Ramphele said some unions still had credibility, such as the National and Professional Teachers' Organisation of SA."
Look she is praise singing a union for white teachers.
She failed to transform UCT when she was in charge. Did you ever hear her criticising DA, plz remind me. People like her offer no solutions, they just bark.
GermanMouser
They’ve go upsoluteley nothing to show. They are just hooligans who needs to be arrested.
andmuchmore
MafikaSkosana
Posted 188 days agoSasha*-Fierce
Hahahaha, Ntate Skosana! Your avatar is one of its kind, lol, parental guidance is advised!
Mangqeshane
Posted 188 days agoThe media has lost the plot completely, they do not know whether they are the PUBLIC's watchdogs or the OPPOSITION
@Mafika Skosana....DAMNNNN!!! your profile pic..
Maxi
Posted 188 days agoGermanMouser
m1si2zi3nzo4
Maxi
Of course those shooting during the apartheid regime were ordered by the then government. People were protesting against the evil laws of the past and the government ordered the police raid than getting rid of those laws. The Marikan thing is a labor dispute between workers and a private company. Government police were there only to guarantee security. Unfortunately the situation became violent when armed workers tried to attack them. In the past people were massacred while protesting peacefully.
m1si2zi3nzo4
Even apartheid refused to be compared with Nazism. Just as the present racist government refuses to accept that fact. Its amazing how language gets used to adjust the minds of the people, due to its ability to create thought. This guarantees a belief that there is no other reality than the one created for the ignorant masses. Dictators learned long ago how to master language. In such way torture and cruelty can be avoided, as systematic forms of control, to achieve abject submission to tyranny.
GermanMouser
Posted 188 days agoWe know who said what via e-mails & we know that they are members of the NEC of the JZ-ANC.
Maxi
GermanMouser
Selftaught
Posted 188 days agoBobbyBob
Posted 188 days agoproud-mbongwa
proud-mbongwa
Posted 188 days ago