Three dead, millions in damages - for R36
Image by: Foto24 / Denzil Maregele / Gallo Images
Weeks of bloody protests, three deaths and millions of rands in damages to property culminated in R36 extra a day in the pockets of Western Cape farmworkers.
After Labour Minister Mildred Oliphant yesterday increased the minimum wage from R69 to R105 a day, neither farmworkers nor farmers were happy.
Nosey Pieterse, secretary of the Builders' and Allied Worker's Union of SA, which was at the centre of the wage strike, dismissed the increase as cold comfort for the families of those who sacrificed their lives and others who starved for a better future.
Michael Daniels, of Wolseley, Bongile Ndleni, of Prince Alfred Hamlet, and Letsekang Thokoane, of De Doorns, were killed during the strike, which started in November.
But the workers were not the only ones who suffered. Farms were set alight, production was severely affected and shops were looted during the strike as workers and youths engaged in running battles with the police.
Daniels, a tractor driver and father of one, died in hospital in November after police allegedly shot at strikers. His family and friends said he was not among the protesters. He had gone to watch the standoff between the police and the workers in town.
In the same month, 40-year-old Ndleni was found dead in his home. Police spokesman Lieutenant-Colonel Andre Traut said he was shot by "individuals driving an LDV". He said there was no evidence to suggest that Ndleni died as a result of police action.
Last month, Thokoane was struck in the head by rubber bullets allegedly fired by police. He died in hospital.
Pieterse said more than 400 farmworkers were facing intimidation and public violence charges and some had lost their jobs.
"The R105 is what is currently being negotiated on the farms and we expected the minister to do better than that," said Pieterse.
"We will have a very difficult task to get workers to accept this. The strike might resume because it was only suspended."
AgriSA chairman Johannes Möller said the 52% increase would take the total wage bill of the agricultural sector from R14-billion to more than R21-billion.
"There will be retrenchments on a large scale because farmers simply cannot absorb the extra R7-billion that comes with a minimum wage of R105," said Möller.
Oliphant said the new minimum wage would start next month.
"This is also a testament to the government's resolve to respond appropriately to the plight of those who are vulnerable in society.
"Without doubt, farmworkers and domestic workers fall within this group and this department will do its utmost to ensure that we make not only their lives better, but design a better deal for labour in general," Oliphant said.
Farmworkers went on strike in November. Things turned violent, production facilities on farms in Paarl and Worcester, and a packing shed in Wellington, were destroyed.
Farms run by black economic empowerment beneficiaries did not escape the violence - 14 suffered about R8.2-million in damages in December.
The Labour Department intervened and reviewed the statutory minimum wage for the sector.
Though the likes of trade union federation Cosatu and Pieterse put up a united front during the strike, they yesterday sang from different hymn sheets. Cosatu welcomed the new deal.
AgriSA's Möller said some agricultural industries could disappear completely as the increase in the minimum wage took hold.
He said the higher minimum wage would cost jobs, change many positions from permanent to temporary and lose the government tax revenue as farmers made losses.
Farmers have already started limiting their exposure to labour-cost spikes by employing more temporary workers.
"The way things are now, farmers in Western Cape have started looking at wine cultivars that are the least labour-intensive," said Möller.
The ANC and the UDM welcomed Oliphant's decision to raise the minimum wage. But Freedom Front Plus leader Pieter Mulder said the R105 minimum wage would lead to large-scale job loses and force farmers to mechanise.
Mulder said farmers will be forced to recalculate their wages bill and that the prices they were paid for agricultural products would not increase at the same rate.
The Transvaal Agricultural Union said the increase "will harm the country", sour labour relations and hit consumers.
It said small and emerging farmers would be the worst hit.


SHARE YOUR OPINION
If you have an opinion you would like to share on this article, please send us an e-mail to the Times LIVE iLIVE team. In the mean time, click here to view the Times LIVE iLIVE section.m1si2zi3nzo4
Posted 103 days agol984
Gormogon1
Posted 103 days agoSuiGeneris
Found this in IOL BussnessReport....
''.....Government pays workers who are part of its official job creation programme as little as R30 per day, according to a report on Saturday.....''
skhokho12
SuiGeneris
leaving wage?.... leaving conditions.....
Really ? Hahaha.
RSA.MommaCyndi
Posted 103 days agoThis 'collective bargaining' is not working at all. Yes, people should not be exploited and everyone should get a CEO's salary every month but it is just not practical. Our farms are not subsidised, mechanised or receiving government support. Our labour is not efficient or cost effective. We cannot put into practice first world practices with third world support and expect to be commercially viable.
Many farms are working on bank loans that would scare me to death. All it will take is one bad season and the farm is bankrupt. The worst affected are going to be new farmers who's farms will be repossessed and a self perpetuating cycle will begin. This will just result in our food security then going down the tubes.
Jakes_Mathews#
Posted 103 days agoStirrer
Posted 103 days agoThat R36 represents a 52% increase in wages. The deaths and the damages were regrettable and probably avoidable - but to desperate people it was merely collateral damage.
Unfortunately, these huge increases (here, and at Marikana) sets dangerous precedents for other industries. They now see that massive wage increases can be achieved by sustained unrest accompanied by acts of vandalism and violence (as opposed to a say 10% increase after a couple of Cosatu-led marches). We should brace ourselves for more such civil action by workers, where Cosatu leads the workers from the rear, instead of leading them from the front!
KafreeMoneykey
Posted 103 days agoThe system is structured to ensure that our generations are trapped in poverty. We did not go to school, whilst our baas' children were being educated. We will watch them get into the school bus whilst we are left to work on a farm...alternatively face a 20 km walk which was not sustainable. After my parents died, we were chased away from the farm we only knew as home...We had no choice but to go and fend for ourselves in the streets until a good samaritan came to our rescue. I might have started schooling at 13 years old but being chased away from my ancestral land was a blessing to me and my sisters. Now we have education and came shape and mould the destiny of our generations. It hurts me so much to still see my childhoods taking over the spades from their parents. It hurts me so much to see my childhood friends taking the bottle of alcohol handed to them by the baas in the name of a reward. To the farmers, is it really difficult just to also educate the farm workers children? Just to give them a ride to school? Just to educate them? Is it really difficult to treat farm workers with dignity and not view them as sub-human with no feelings? Being a farm worker's child is the same as being a child soldier in the DRC, that is how it feels or rather that is how I felt when I saw the other side of life "
End quote...
Now, how can the civil action by the workers be due to Cosatu or the ANC?
i_stub_born
Wiseguy
Posted 103 days agoThe dop system your quote mentions was/is truely appalling and has been directly implicated in the high foetal alcohol sysdrome(FAS) incidence we have in this country. It is outlawed by current legislation and been banned, but unfortunately is still practiced by some!
I still feel, profit share for the farm workers was the long term solution required to this problem and hopefully forward thinking farmers will look closely at their books! If they cannot afford the new wages, please negotiate a profit share solution with your workers......it is a win-win situation for all
Malwanza
Posted 103 days agoKafreeMoneykey
Posted 103 days agoI have been following you guys but just did not have time to comment!