INSIGHT | Turkey earthquake: Why reconstruction could miss Erdogan's goal

Sheltering in a converted shipping container, Ismet Kaplan waits to hear if he's eligible for one of hundreds of thousands of homes President Tayyip Erdogan promised would replace those ruined by modern Turkey's deadliest earthquake in February.

Days after the quake and with a national election looming, Erdogan made bold promises. While survivors were still emerging from rubble, he said half of the disaster zone would be rebuilt within a year — 319,000 homes.

Eight months on, more than a dozen officials, builders and engineers said rising construction costs and economic uncertainty have deterred companies from bidding for government reconstruction contracts, making that deadline look hard to reach, especially in the worst-hit areas.

With work under way on a fraction of the planned new buildings in the devastated city of Adiyaman, Kaplan fears a long wait with his disabled wife and other survivors. They are exposed to summer and winter temperatures in the lines of containers set up as temporary housing after the February 6 disaster.

“I believe it will take years to move,” said Kaplan, whose apartment block collapsed in the quake. His daughter, daughter-in-law and four grandchildren died under falling buildings.

By the government's account, 40,000 homes will be ready by the end of November, leaving three months to finish nearly 280,000.

One senior government official with direct knowledge of the reconstruction plan said the target could be missed, citing insufficient funding to hold new tenders amid rising costs. Another cited budget constraints and said new measures were needed to speed things up.

Both said the effort had taken a blow when fewer companies bid for the reconstruction tenders after a post-election economic policy U-turn in June sent the currency plunging.

The officials requested anonymity.

In response to questions, Erdogan's office said construction was on schedule and in line with announced targets, saying work had started on 200,000 homes and “those completed will be delivered stage by stage in October, November and December”.

“The disaster zone is the government's priority,” it said, denying a slowdown in tenders, without providing numbers.

By August 6, construction was under way on 123,000 homes, according to a Reuters review of the most recent public ministry data, covering the six months from the earthquake.

The data also showed construction had only started on 7% of almost 65,000 homes the government promised would be completed in Adiyaman province within two years of the quake.

Ufuk Bayir, secretary-general of the Union of Chambers of Turkish Engineers and Architects (TMMOB) in Adiyaman, said work had started on more homes, but predicted just a few hundred will be delivered to Adiyaman residents by the end of the year. TMMOB is aligned with Turkey's left-wing opposition.

“I see no possibility of all houses being delivered in a year,” said Bayir, who is also a member Adiyaman's Provincial Coordination Council.

MILLIONS HOMELESS

Kaplan, a retired court clerk, checks the official online housing portal regularly. The first response to his June application for a home came last month, saying his request was “being assessed”.

“We have nowhere else to stay and I don't know how we will survive the winter,” Kaplan said.

Tens of thousands of buildings still await demolition across the disaster zone, and like Kaplan, many survivors remain in tents and container homes as winter approaches in a region where temperatures can drop below freezing.

Rattling an area the size of the Netherlands and Belgium combined, the predawn quake flattened entire towns and city centres in the textile- and agriculture-heavy southeast, killing more than 50,000 people.

Nearly 300,000 buildings toppled or were left unusable and millions were left homeless, including war refugees from neighbouring Syria, where the earthquake also killed thousands.

Erdogan said 680,000 homes will be finished within two years under a government-funded scheme that will see homeowners repay the costs interest free over 20 years.

A public website showed about five project tenders a day in April, before slowing in May. The data stopped being disclosed on May 31. Reuters could not establish how many tenders have been issued since. The urbanisation ministry did not respond to a question about why the data stopped being published.

The ministry, the state housing agency and the public procurement authority did not respond to questions on the latest construction figures.

Urbanisation minister Mehmet Ozhaseki and other government officials have publicly stood by Erdogan's deadlines. The minister acknowledged in mid-September it was “not an easy task” for the state housing agency to build so many homes when it usually builds 60,000 to 70,000 annually.

In a move that could help speed up reconstruction, last week the president's office published a decree allowing grants and interest-free loans for homeowners to build houses in the disaster area.

LOCAL ELECTIONS

In hard-hit Hatay, Malatya, Adiyaman and Kahramanmaras, which together account for nearly 80% of the homes planned by 2025, work started on only 15% of them by August, a Reuters analysis of the official data showed. The presidency said Hatay and Kahramanmaras cities were not behind schedule.

More progress has been made in other affected provinces, Gaziantep and the smaller Kilis, where, by August, work began on about half of about 45,000 homes promised over two years, the official data shows. The government did not respond to questions about why work was more advanced in these regions.

Disaster reconstruction usually takes several years in order to provide well-planned water, sewage, electricity systems, and other infrastructure, Arvid Tuerkner, Turkey MD at the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, said in an interview after a visit to the disaster zone in September.

Any delays in rebuilding the southeast could play a role in the March voting, when Erdogan's AK Party (AKP) aims to recover the municipal governments in Istanbul, Ankara and other big cities lost to the opposition in 2019.

Mert Arslanalp, assistant professor of political science at Istanbul's Bogazici University, said Erdogan's promise to rebuild the area in a year helped him sustain support in the May presidential vote.

“So a failure to deliver on his promises may have ramifications in the local elections,” he said.

PRICE TAG

In March, Ankara estimated the earthquake's cost to be $104bn (now about R2-trillion) and said rebuilding would account for more than half.

After he was appointed in June, finance minister Mehmet Simsek said the disaster's budget impact was “huge” at nearly 10% of GDP, mostly felt over two years. The quake accounts for nearly half of this year's expected budget deficit-to-GDP ratio.

Partly in response, Simsek raised taxes. He also made a U-turn to more orthodox policies, including sharp interest rate hikes to address inflation, which is expected to rise above 65% by the end of the year.

As part of the U-turn, authorities loosened their grip on the lira, triggering a 26% depreciation since the end of May to record lows and compounding expenses for developers.

Rising costs “severely reduced” predictability and left companies reluctant to bid, the senior government official said.

Up to 70% of costs for Turkish construction companies are indexed to the dollar, according to the head of one major company working on reconstruction with the government, who asked to remain anonymous.

Based on previous practice, the government is likely to raise the money on offer for tenders and increase what it pays builders to cover rising construction expenses.

“Our budget resources have been prepared for this huge, comprehensive project and can be updated when necessary,” Erdogan's office said.

Costs this year had, in reality, almost doubled, said Tahir Tellioglu, president of the Construction Contractors Confederation, citing inflation, the weak lira and wage hikes.

“We've come to a tipping point and the sector cannot take it any more,” Tellioglu said.”

In Adiyaman, Bayir said contractors struggled to keep workers, with rivals increasing wages to poach them.

Umit Oktay, a 48-year old welder in Hatay, has been sheltering since April in a container with his wife and three children, and like others is staying put because of the promise of a new home.

“It is almost impossible to move around inside the container home, which looks like a chicken coop,” he said. “But I do not have faith we'll live in a proper house this winter.”

Additional reporting: Ezgi Erkoyun, Nevzat Devranoglu and Jonathan Spicer.

Reuters