Circus comes to town but animal rights activists not impressed

14 July 2023 - 18:25 By MFUNDO MKHIZE
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
A packed house at the McLaren circus in Durban. The circus has been criticised by animal lovers
A packed house at the McLaren circus in Durban. The circus has been criticised by animal lovers
Image: Supplied

McLaren Circus has come to Durban but anti-animal cruelty organisation Ban Animal Trade is not happy, saying the use of animals is an “exploitive and gross violation of their rights” and adds no educational value. 

This comes after a social media debate after a Durban man left the circus after seeing a tiger being poked during a recent performance.

The organisation’s director Prathna Singh said McLaren's competitors had long stopped using animals after a furore.

“Its just unethical,” she said.

“Others who had watched the show had told of the horror of seeing some of the animals in compromising positions. We believe no animal should be kept in captivity for human benefit,” said Singh.

Lions in their enclosure outside the Maclaren Circus which is currently in Durban
Lions in their enclosure outside the Maclaren Circus which is currently in Durban
Image: Supplied

The organisation has also been vociferous in challenging the use of horses at the Hollywood Bets Durban July event.

Singh said there had been a global shift towards banning animals from being used at circuses.

“We are opposed to animals being removed from their natural habitat which is the wild.”

She said the circus profited by using animals.

“All natural behaviour is taken away from them.”

The circus' public relations officer Karl Hildebrandt said the controversy over the animals had not resulted in a dip in ticket sales.

“Throughout all this time we had enjoyed a succession of sold-out shows in Durban,” said Hildebrandt.

He said since the show started last month the company had had more than five inspections by the Durban SPCA which found they had not flouted any laws.

“In all those instances we have never been found to be in the wrong, not received any warning,” said Hildebrandt.

“Animals in South Africa have been a huge drawcard for audiences. However the recent years have shown the special relationship that our animal trainers maintain with our animals.

“It’s important for us as a business that includes performing animals to convey how we can have a beautiful relationship with the animals when caring and bonding with them,” said Hildebrandt.

National council of SPCA spokesperson Shayla Knipe confirmed they had received a complaint.

“The NSPCA is opposed to the keeping and or breeding of indigenous and exotic wild species in captivity for reasons other than for bona fide conservation purposes, for rehabilitation and or sanctuary purposes in facilities approved by the SPCA,” said Knipe.

She confirmed that the local SPCA had responded to complaints about the circus and condition of the animals to determine whether there are any contraventions of the Animal Protection Act.

“Because circuses travel, SPCAs nationwide continually inspect circuses when they visit their area. The NSPCA is aware of several complaints against circuses using animals in their acts and we actively monitor the situation.”

Chatsworth father Ashay Baijnath said he was aware of the flak about circus animals.

“I have not really seen it yet. But I would also be turned off if there was gross abuse of animals. Having said that it is always a thrill to see some of the animals,” said Baijnath.

Westville resident Paul Johnston, 66, who is a fan of circus shows, said he been made aware of a growing calls for animals not to be used by circuses.

“But I must say that I had not witnessed any cruelty during some of the shows,” he said.

TimesLIVE

Support independent journalism by subscribing to TimesLIVE Premium. Just R80 per month.


subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now

Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.