The plight of Cape Town's homeless goes political
When Strandfontein ward councillor Elton Jansen was told his community would carry the burden of housing thousands of homeless people on the local sports field, he was not happy.
He was not consulted, he said, and he admitted it was a burden no councillor in any Cape Town suburb would willingly bear.
“No councillor or any ratepayer would like a site for street people in their ward, understandably so, because there are a lot of underlying factors that are connected to street people. But we need to find a way to deal with this matter, and that is where I’m at now,” he said.
He had no choice. This is a military-enforced national lockdown. This is the Covid-19 pandemic, which is wreaking havoc across the globe, decimating health systems in first-world countries and taking tens of thousands of lives.
“I was informed, and I said in my post [on Facebook on Tuesday] I was unhappy because I was not consulted. And I stick to that, because I was not consulted," said Jansen.
"But we have this plight here now. We have this concern with street people and the fight against Covid-19, and I really want to change the focus of me being unhappy due to not being consulted - which is a fact - and change the direction, because we now have the street people on our doorstep and we need to deal with it.”
A fleet of buses started depopulating the streets of Cape Town on Tuesday. The city’s newsafe space in Culemborg, under the N2, was evacuated and its residents moved out by midday.
At the site in Strandfontein a massive logistical operation was under way. Marquees were being erected to house facilities including a large medical centre and an isolation facility complete with portable showers.
At least three separate tents were erected to house homeless people who were grouped together according to their suburbs of origin.
Pressure was already mounting against the city from the ANC and the Good Party, which criticised the city’s approach of centralising nearly 2,000 homeless people at a site they claimed was unfit for the purpose. They also accused the council of using the Covid-19 pandemic as an excuse to get rid of Cape Town’s homelessness problem.
“The City of Cape Town must immediately shelve its medieval plans to dump homeless residents in marquees in the mud on the outskirts of town,” said Good Party secretary-general Brett Herron, who called the Strandfontein facility a "cincentration camp".
“Available options include the above-ground parking garages of the civic centre, the stadiums, empty government buildings like the Tafelberg School — or renting empty buildings from private property owners.
“The city should be ashamed at its opportunistic abuse of the coronavirus pandemic to forcibly remove homeless people from city and suburban environs and dump them on the Strandfontein sports ground.”
The ANC Youth League’s regional convenor, Bulelani Yosana, accused the city and the provincial government of being “cruel, heartless and ruthless” in their treatment of the homeless.
On Tuesday afternoon a “riot” broke out at one of the camps for the homeless inside the city. Social media users spread videos of people running and shouting and breaking down a fence.
Herron said it was “no surprise to hear this afternoon that law enforcement officials at the internment camp had their hands full containing angry victims of this cruel city policy”.
Mayoral committee member for safety and security JP Smith referred to the situation as a “scuffle”.
He said: “We can ... confirm that there was some conflict on-site, involving a newly arrived group of street people from Somerset West.”
He claimed the situation arose because individuals were under the impression that they would be able to return to their areas after being screened.
“When it became clear that they were required to remain in Strandfontein, a few of them pulled down one of the internal fences and four climbed over the perimeter wall,” he said.
Three of the four people who fled were apprehended.
“While some of the group have since indicated that they will remain on site, the city would like to make it clear that, according to SAPS, any person who leaves the site will be in violation of the national lockdown regulations and will be dealt with accordingly,” said Smith.
Jo Swart, chairperson of the Somerset West nightshelter, denied that 29 people who boarded the bus to Strandfontein had been misled.
“They weren’t under any wrong impression that they were going to Strandfontein for the course of the lockdown. They were fully informed. I think when they got there the understanding of what they saw was just something they wanted to rebel from," she said.
“These street people are coming off drugs, they’re coming off alcohol, there’s a whole other dynamic to it. They get to a field, they’re hungry, there’s anxiety and clearly the camp was heading towards not being manageable because they’ve spent the whole day today not sending any more buses. We’ve been waiting for another bus and now we’ve just got news that the site is full and locked down and closed.”
As if anticipating the fiasco which was to follow on Thursday when the city invited 30 media representatives to a site visit led by council officials, Jansen said he wanted to urge political parties not to play politics.
“As much as we are unhappy about the lack of consultation, we need to make sure the community is protected in the event of anyone jumping the fence," he said.
“Now is not the time to play politics. It is sad that we’re using this opportunity now, whilst we’re supposed to take the lead from President Cyril Ramaphosa where he invited all political parties in parliament they made that joint statement, yet here on the ground we’re fighting amongst one another.”
On Thursday, mayoral committee member for health and community services Zahid Badroodien, Smith and mayor Dan Plato led the media contingent through the site.
Only a handful of journalists were allowed into the camp the previous day, others were told the introduction of journalists with cameras would spark a volatile situation.
Badroodien said the council was not “trying to keep secrets about what it is that we are wanting to achieve here, about what we’re doing here”.
He added: “When the lockdown was announced by the president we had three days to achieve what it is that he had set to be a mammoth task for the city, the temporary housing of almost 6,000 homeless people in the city.”
He said Strandfontein was chosen because it was the largest site with a wall and access to utilities such as water and electricity.
People were screened for Covid-19, TB and criminal records. He said 11 people who tested positive for TB were being held in an isolation area and would be moved to a hospital. Twelve people were being isolated pending the results of Covid-19 tests.
“You are asking me about public participation and I will offer to you there was no time for public participation,” said Badroodien.
He said if a public participation process had been followed the city would still be waiting for a space to house thousands of homeless people.
“I’m very grateful to the ward councillor for informing his community of what was a very difficult decision that we as a city had had to take and also difficult for the councillor to have to inform the community that this decision was taken at a facility that is very active where soccer and cricket is played,” he said.
Smith said there were not enough mattresses at the facility and the NGO the council had relied on to supply the mattresses was having transport issues. But supply chain management procedures were being overridden in order to secure enough mattresses for all the camp’s inhabitants.
When the media contingent arrived at one of the large tents where homeless people were standing in a queue for food, there were complaints about the conditions in the camp.
There’s not enough food, claimed residents. They also said they were being held against their will and were not able to leave.
Smith denied this, saying people could “opt out” and were doing so at a rate of four a day.
Watched by Plato and Smith, and in the presence of the cameras, the situation rapidly escalated. One of the people picked up a discarded bone and threw it at Smith. Others then started pulling and pushing the fence.
While Badroodien waited for homeless “representatives” of three suburbs to come and speak to the media about their experiences, two women approached to say they were being held at the site against their will and complained about the conditions.
Wanita Davis from Wellington said she was rounded up by the police and taken to the facility after social workers took her daughter away.
“The social workers took my baby because of the coronavirus. After that I had to stay on the street because I didn’t want to go without my baby," she said.
"On Sunday they just came with the van and said, 'come, come, you must go', but by force. We didn’t have time to take our clothes or anything. I’m wearing the same clothes and the same underwear, it’s not right.”
Crying, Davis claimed that they were pepper sprayed by the law enforcement officers guarding the camp.
Badroodien denied the claims. He said many people at the camp were suffering from drug withdrawal and mental illness, creating the conditions for an incendiary situation.
Yhe representatives chosen by officials to talk to the media said the service provider taking care of them on behalf of the city was providing them with four meals a day.
Alicia, a homeless resident from Wynberg, said she was confused about the situation around Covid-19.
“When I got here, I got treated, we got screening. At the moment we’ve got 500 in a tent, none of us has the virus. Those of them that think they have the virus were separated. At the moment we are getting four meals a day and we are getting washed and everything,” she said.
“It’s very scary about this virus going on, we are just very confused about this virus.”
Shirley January from Muizenberg said there were 500 people in her tent. Various promises had been made to them before they were taken to Strandfontein, but none had been met.
She said, however, that the service provider at their camp, Oasis, was making sure they were well taken care of.
“When we came here, we were told we were going to have two meals a day, but then out of their own pockets they are providing us with four meals a day and they gave us some netball poles and board games. There’s a lot of activities and they’re just keeping us alive,” said January.
Alicia said that they needed information on what was happening with Covid-19. “It’s not like it’s a vacation for us. We need to move on with our lives, please”.
The homeless people at the Strandfontein sports complex trying to jump the fence out of frustration at being on lockdown at the site. The City started relocating them to the site aimed at curbing the spread of Covid-19.@TimesLIVE @homeless @Covid19InSA pic.twitter.com/1Ok81VLZab— Esa Alexander (@ezaap) April 10, 2020
After they spoke, ANC Western Cape leader Cameron Dugmore took the seat previously occupied by Plato during a news conference.
He claimed he was denied entrance to the facility before laying into the city for what he claimed was its mismanagement of the homelessness situation.
“What we’ve seen today is an indication that the attempt by the city to want to locate every homeless person in one particular venue is wrong and it’s not sustainable,” he said.
“I think the approach of local communities finding solutions — whether someone comes from Sea Point, whether someone comes from Bellville, Athlone, Gugulethu — looking at localised solutions because street people actually come from areas, they don’t live in the air,” he said.
“In the situation that we saw today we first consulted with the ratepayer associations, with the policing forums, they weren’t expecting detailed consultation, but they’ve been asking from the beginning for an operational plan, that has never been shared with them.”
Dugmore said these organisations, which wanted to help, had not been brought “into the loop. As MPs we were asked to be taken around. Then we went in, we went into the last camp,” he said.
He said there were no mattresses, and residents complained they had not been fed and there was no soap in the showers.
These were some of the scenes at the City of Cape Town's #Strandfontein facility during a media tour on Thursday. Some street people claimed they were taken to the site against their will by the police and law enforcement officials. The facility houses about 2000 people. #Covid19 pic.twitter.com/eJzl3L4jJ2— Aron Hyman (@aron_hyman) April 9, 2020
He said volunteers and law enforcement officers reported that they had been given no protective equipment.
“Law enforcement officers told us that they themselves had to buy sanitiser and masks,” he said.
“We will be urgently ... giving a report to our national ministers, and we want to appeal to the national and the provincial and the local government, this particular approach is not sustainable.”
Dugmore said that while community halls were being earmarked as quarantine facilities, there there were plenty of facilities in the city that could have been used to house the homeless.
“Our visit here — I’m leader of the opposition, my colleague is on the social development committee — I don’t think you heard the word ANC once, we actually are here because as public reps we are essential services workers, we’ve got permits to travel,” said Dugmore.
It was the trigger to a shouting match. “You are making assertions which are trite!” Smith shouted across the tent at Dugmore.
“Start with giving sanitiser to your law enforcement officers,” Dugmore responded.
“50,000 litres of sanitiser ...” said Smith.
“I’ll take you to five who’ve got no sanitiser,” said Dugmore.
Plato stood in the corner of the tent, with an embarrassed look on his face. “JP ...” he said under his breath, watching the situation unfold.
Outside, Jansen stood in the shade of the tent, embarrassed to bear witness. What he had warned about the day before was unfolding, and he reiterated his sentiments.
“There have been some high-level squabbles which we’ve all observed and I urge all of us to forget about what party we belong to and put our heads together to fight this common enemy," he said.
"Now it’s not ANC vs DA, our common enemy is the coronavirus and people are going to die.”