Zondo accepts Duduzane Zuma's request for cross-examination‚ rejects Guptas'

13 September 2018 - 11:40 By Amil Umraw
Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo said the commission sees no reason to give the Gupta family “special treatment”.
Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo said the commission sees no reason to give the Gupta family “special treatment”.
Image: Gallo Images / Sowetan / Thulani Mbele

Deputy chief justice Raymond Zondo has granted Duduzane Zuma leave to cross-examine former deputy finance minister Mcebisi Jonas.

The same, however, cannot be said for Ajay and Rajesh Gupta.

Zondo said whereas Ajay and Rajesh are outside the country and are not prepared to return‚ Zuma is currently in South Africa and has changed his previous decision not to avail himself to the commission as he is facing criminal charges on the same allegations.

The Gupta brothers made a joint application to cross-examine Jonas‚ former ANC MP Vytjie Mentor and former GCIS boss Themba Maseko. The brothers said they would testify before the commission if it travelled to neutral location outside South Africa or via a video conference.

“They [Ajay and Rajesh] say that they are presently in the United Arab Emirates‚ that they have no intention of ever returning to South Africa for any reason whatsoever‚ and that the reason why in effect is that they are afraid that the Hawks will arrest them as a result of what they call incompetence on the part of the Hawks‚ and that they may be charged by the National Prosecuting Authority‚ which they say is also incompetent‚” Zondo said‚ paraphrasing a supplementary affidavit the commission received from the brothers.

“I am of the view that Ajay and Rajesh have no valid reason for not being prepared to return to South Africa and appear before this commission…

“It seems to me that the issue of this commission travelling overseas to hear their submissions must be rejected.”

Zondo said the commission sees no reason to give the Gupta family “special treatment”.

“As long as they are not prepared to personally and physically appear before the commission within the borders of South Africa‚ their application cannot be granted - but once they are in the borders of South Africa and are prepared to appear before the commission‚ I would have no difficulty in granting them permission to cross-examine‚" he said.

"They must make their decision.”

Deputy Chief Justice Raymond rejected the Guptas’ request to cross-examine witnesses in the state capture inquiry on Thursday September 13 2018.

X