Our panel of judges nibbled their way through hot cross buns from five leading supermarkets in a quest to find the tastiest ones on the market
HOW WE CONDUCTED OUR TASTE TEST
We put out a call to our readers to be part of the panel of tasters.
They came together on a Saturday morning and were presented with hot cross buns from five leading supermarkets - with no branding - on separate plates. The buns were served warm without butter to enable a truer test in terms of texture, fruit, spice and freshness.
Auditor Jade Craig was on hand to monitor the objectivity of the blind-tasting process, from removing the packaging to numbering the products, overseeing the preparation and adding up the score sheets.
THE RESULTS
First place: Pick n Pay 6 traditional hot cross buns
Judges' comments: These buns scored high on appearance, with a shiny glaze and consistent crosses. The panel liked the soft, light texture and good amount of fruit and spices.
Price: R14.99
Second place: Woolworths 6 traditional hot cross buns
Judges' comments: The buns were not glazed but tasters liked their golden-brown colour. They looked and tasted fresh, but some tasters found them a little on the dry side.
Price: R21.99
story_article_right1
Third place: Checkers 6 bakery hot cross buns
Judges' comments: Appearance was good although most tasters felt the buns lacked spice.
Price: R15.99
Fourth place: Food Lovers Market: 6 hot cross buns
Judges' comments: Despite their attractive appearance, these buns were deemed "not very fresh".
Price: R14.99
Fifth place: SPAR 6 hot cross buns
Judges' comments: The buns were described as doughy and as having little or no spice. There was no glaze and most said the amount of fruit was stingy.
Price: R17.99
Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package. 