Motoring

From BMW to Kia: Car logo rebrands that left us scratching our heads

If something isn't broken, why fix it?

31 January 2021 - 00:01 By brenwin naidu
subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now
The new VW logo is seen on the hood of the Volkswagen ID.3 electric car at the 2019 IAA Frankfurt Auto Show.
The new VW logo is seen on the hood of the Volkswagen ID.3 electric car at the 2019 IAA Frankfurt Auto Show.
Image: Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Carmakers probably spend as much money on marketing and brand awareness as they do on the development of products.

A great deal of cash is inevitably splashed on committees whose job it is to name new models, for example. Obviously that's a little easier if you're Audi or BMW, where the simple alphanumeric arrangement cuts the mustard. But what about a brand like Hyundai? Yes, people were paid to pick titles like Sonata, Venue, Tucson and Palisade.

Not to single out the South Korean brand - there are many peculiar car names out there - but the automaker does make for a good reference point.

Some car makers have opted to rebrand, as the motoring world forges ahead into electrified, autonomous territories. But in some cases, the attempt to refresh an identity comes across as a misstep.

If something is not broken, why fix it?

Take Volkswagen, with its new monochrome 2D logo. It looks clean and uncluttered on the advertising material and adorning the entrances of dealerships, but on the vehicles it looks cheap compared to the chromed 3D emblem being phased out.

BMW also redesigned its blue-and-white roundel, with a clear background instead of a black one. It errs on the flat side - and although the emblems affixed to the current crop of cars thankfully remain unchanged, the new design is likely to be introduced in forthcoming models.

The old and new BMW logo.
The old and new BMW logo.
Image: Supplied

American giant General Motors (GM) also went back to the drawing board recently. And the stylised pair of letters that had been penned are … interesting, to say the least.

The bold, dark blue, upper-case setup has been ditched for a softer, cursive-type font in a lighter colour that puts one in mind of the former Intel computers' swirl logo.

Okay, maybe the move is appropriate, giving the impression of that shift from serious, monolithic automobile conglomerate to friendly provider of "mobility solutions" for an ever-changing planet. A good symbol has to communicate such subtleties, I suppose.

The new General Motors logo.
The new General Motors logo.
Image: Supplied
The new Kia logo.
The new Kia logo.
Image: Supplied

But the new Kia banner leaves me scratching my head as to what exactly the firm is trying to communicate. If its aim was to get people squinting, then it's done a stellar job.

You don't have to be Andy Rice to know that a successful logo is supposed to be instantly recognisable. The "I" looks more like an "L" or "V" here. You can tell its people were going for an edgier appearance. Great, but could they not have attempted a more legible script with defined letters?

This rant is unlikely to prompt the head honchos of the companies mentioned to seriously reconsider their rebranding efforts. And sure, the average buyer is unlikely to boycott a brand because they dislike the emblem on its vehicles' snout. But if you're the boss of a global carmaker and you're reading this, know that these moves don't go unnoticed. We see you. 


subscribe Just R20 for the first month. Support independent journalism by subscribing to our digital news package.
Subscribe now

Would you like to comment on this article?
Sign up (it's quick and free) or sign in now.

Speech Bubbles

Please read our Comment Policy before commenting.